Re:The second operating system hiding in every mobile phone
by mindslight on Sunday November 17, 2013 @08:45PM
(#6752033)
> you're assuming that those that created the system consider known identity to be a misfeature
No, I'm just speaking from the perspective of system design, for what it would take to actually hide your location data - to put boundaries on the problem we're talking about.
> trusted ... means that you have given the entity your private information
Yes, which is why I used "trustable", which I'll admit isn't necessarily the best word either as I'm currently trusting my phone with call/text data, even knowing how broken it is. On the other hand, I personally don't have my phone setup to access my general files, because I simply don't feel that the thing in my pocket is actually my agent.
> physical audit would tell you if the MEMS sensor in your device has been repurposed for audio pickup
Well the point is that a Mifi (with untrusted baseband) shouldn't have these sensors.
> Intel CPUs have features that actively work against you, such as with vPRO.
And probably other ones ones that don't show up in marketing materials. Which is why I made an explicit parallel to trusting Intel CPUs to generally run the code we tell them, even if this isn't necessarily true. We have to define a boundary so that we can solve the problem we're talking about with a platonic ideal of a trustable CPU, while separately solving the problem of not having trustable CPUs.
No, I'm just speaking from the perspective of system design, for what it would take to actually hide your location data - to put boundaries on the problem we're talking about.
> trusted ... means that you have given the entity your private information
Yes, which is why I used "trustable", which I'll admit isn't necessarily the best word either as I'm currently trusting my phone with call/text data, even knowing how broken it is. On the other hand, I personally don't have my phone setup to access my general files, because I simply don't feel that the thing in my pocket is actually my agent.
> physical audit would tell you if the MEMS sensor in your device has been repurposed for audio pickup
Well the point is that a Mifi (with untrusted baseband) shouldn't have these sensors.
> Intel CPUs have features that actively work against you, such as with vPRO.
And probably other ones ones that don't show up in marketing materials. Which is why I made an explicit parallel to trusting Intel CPUs to generally run the code we tell them, even if this isn't necessarily true. We have to define a boundary so that we can solve the problem we're talking about with a platonic ideal of a trustable CPU, while separately solving the problem of not having trustable CPUs.