News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Achieving 10Gbps Line-rate Key-value Stores with FPGAs [pdf] by justincormack on Sunday November 17, 2013 @05:47PM (#6751405)
Yes, more memcache like. Its a research project not a production system.
Re:Achieving 10Gbps Line-rate Key-value Stores with FPGAs [pdf] by Nrsolis on Sunday November 17, 2013 @05:56PM (#6751446)
What I'm not getting from this is why it's any different from a properly implemented TCAM.

Key/value lookups are something that's done by existing networking hardware very well. There are existing merchant-silicon chipsets that do this on-die very well.

There was once an evolving market for "network processor units" but it looks like that all cooled down. IIRC, there was an effort to do something akin to a database lookup on an NPU, but the tradeoff between flexibility and what the NPUs could provide wasn't amenable to the kind of work required to bring those solutions to market.

Re:Achieving 10Gbps Line-rate Key-value Stores with FPGAs [pdf] by bakul on Sunday November 17, 2013 @08:17PM (#6751952)
TCAMs have three problems for such applications: 1) limited key length (usually less than 64 bytes) 2) power-hungry as you are comparing against every key 3) limited size -- try getting a 4GB TCAM!
Re:Achieving 10Gbps Line-rate Key-value Stores with FPGAs [pdf] by cwzwarich on Sunday November 17, 2013 @06:03PM (#6751471)
At least as far as I understand the article, it's simplified in that it can drop store requests without breaking its semantic guarantees. Implementing full CAMs on FPGAs is pretty inefficient.
Re:Achieving 10Gbps Line-rate Key-value Stores with FPGAs [pdf] by dchichkov on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:52PM (#6752393)
Something's fishy. What was your measurement platform? It feels like, you should have been doing much better than "4-5us" (what was your 99.9 percentile, BTW?) with your FPGA approach. Unless you are doing TCP/IP. But it looked like you are not, right? It is just UDP?