Re:Julia 0.2 released
by rcthompson on Sunday November 17, 2013 @06:07PM
(#6751483)
Thanks for the explanation. What do you mean by "It doesn't support any sort of type hierarchy"? I've contributed to a package that defines some S4 methods on a base class and relies on that implementation being called on derived classes as well.
Re:Julia 0.2 released
by StefanKarpinski on Sunday November 17, 2013 @07:08PM
(#6751676)
This may be a misunderstanding on my part because I am by no means an R expert (I've done a fair amount of stats work in R, but no library development). Can you add a method for base class "Foo" which will automatically apply to "Bar" which is a subtype of "Foo"?
Re:Julia 0.2 released
by rcthompson on Monday November 18, 2013 @04:49AM
(#6753533)
As far as I know, yes, this works just fine. We rely on this in the BiocParallel package in Bioconductor.
Due to not being a deep language feature, S4 lacks some crucial abilities. It doesn't support any sort of type hierarchy besides the special "ANY" class. Without the ability to define a type hierarchy and program to abstract types, most of the power of multiple dispatch evaporates. Even though it is technically an implementation detail, I've found that performance is a critical feature for multiple dispatch to really come into its own. R's S4 dispatch has been described as "slower than S3" [1] – and S3 dispatch is not exactly fast. Unless really basic things like + and array indexing can be generic and usably fast, you're not really cooking with gas.
[1] http://www.r-project.org/conferences/useR-2004/Keynotes/Leis...