News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by tbrake on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:32AM (#6749295)
Fortunately for Vishy, Magnus is a fighter who wants to play interesting chess, and this will at least give him a chance as in the 3rd round. Carlsen has unmatched playing strength and I feel if he truly wanted a draw in each of the last six games he could force one and there would be little Anand could do about it. Were he another grandmaster I could see this being the case and it's certainly a legitimate tactic after taking the lead in a game limited match.

Ultimately I think Carlsen will win regardless - he's simply too strong and has been for a long time; if anything the title is overdue to be his.

Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by wslh on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:47AM (#6749354)
Ultimately I think Carlsen will win regardless - he's simply too strong and has been for a long time

Is it time for a new generation of competition between Carlsen and machines?

Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by pi-rat on Sunday November 17, 2013 @11:26AM (#6749520)
The creator of Houdini 3 (one of the strongest chess solvers) was interviewed about it recently, he said the software is so good that it would probably win 8 times out of 10 (2 draws) against someone of Carlsen's strength. Carlsen on the other hand says that he doesn't care, it's not something he even thinks about.. And it's natural I guess, think back to the early days of any technology, people would do stuff faster, then after a while it doesn't even matter, nobody thinks about it. The days of chess man vs machine was back in the days of Deep Blue.

There is a really young chinese kid that's a real rising chess-whiz, give him a few more years and he will give Carlsen a real challenge. It's time for the new generation of chess players indeed :)

Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by petegrif on Sunday November 17, 2013 @12:26PM (#6749747)
Wrt 'young Chinese kid' - Wei Yi - he is indeed a prodigy but there have been many prodigies and whilst they all end up very very vyer strong players by no means all of them challenge for the top spot. If you look at the list of youngest GMs http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Chess_prodigy#List_of_youngest_... you will see that of all these prodigies only a very small number are current super GMs with any real chance at the very top spot. Even Karjakin (a GM at 12) is currently not at that level. For what it's worth my tip to be a serious challenge is Caruana.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by asdfologist on Sunday November 17, 2013 @01:09PM (#6749988)
Even Caruana has plateaued a bit the last few years, whereas Carlsen just keeps getting stronger. At Caruana's age, Carlsen's ELO was well into the 2800s. Right now Carlsen's competition looks pretty bleak.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by petegrif on Sunday November 17, 2013 @03:20PM (#6750644)
Yes - I can't justify my instinct here. I believe there have only ever been 7 players >2800 ELO and Caruana is one of them. But of those Kasparov is retired and Anand, Topalov and probably Kramnik have probably peaked. That leaves Carlsen - out on his own - and Aronian and Caruana. Aronian has probably peaked (he is 31)which leaves Caruana. The next 2-3 years should tell us what he is capable of.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by tbrake on Sunday November 17, 2013 @10:53AM (#6749387)
Probably not. I think that battle is over

I enjoy the pragmatic stance of Anand on the matter http://www.chessquotes.com/player-anand :

There are some things we do much better than computers, but since most of chess is tactically based they do many things better than humans. And this imbalance remains. I no longer have any issues. It’s bit like asking an astronomer, does he mind that a telescope does all the work. He is used to it. It is just an incredible tool that you can use.

Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by wslh on Friday November 22, 2013 @03:14PM (#6783419)
The battle is not over, look at the last comment thread. It seems computers didn't predict what Carlsen saw: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6780928
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by petegrif on Sunday November 17, 2013 @11:04AM (#6749434)
Agreed. In fact you have to be an incredibly strong player (2600+) to not be wiped off the board in around 20 moves these days. The Bulgarian cheater who was recently banned regularly crushed GMs - it was scary.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by richardw on Sunday November 17, 2013 @12:14PM (#6749685)
I only became aware of the issue when reading these articles [1]. It's possible there's some leeway he's owed. I don't know enough about it, obviously.

[1] http://en.chessbase.com/post/a-gro-miscarriage-of-justice-in...

Full paper:

http://en.chessbase.com/portals/4/files/news/2011/riis01.pdf

Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by pk2200 on Sunday November 17, 2013 @12:36PM (#6749792)
The "Bulgarian cheater" he's referring to is Borislav Ivanov (http://en.chessbase.com/tagged?tag=Cheating). The evidence against him is overwhelming, especially this statistical analysis of Ivanov's games (http://www.cse.buffalo.edu/~regan/chess/fidelity/ACPcover-an...)

The links you posted are about Vasik Rajlich, who was banned from the World Computer Chess Championships over allegations of GPL violations.

Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by petegrif on Sunday November 17, 2013 @12:28PM (#6749753)
That's right. I was referring to Ivanov and he was well and truly busted recently and has now 'retired.'
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by wslh on Sunday November 17, 2013 @11:20AM (#6749500)
But, don't you think that there is room for improvement on the humand side? probably with creativity.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by pi-rat on Sunday November 17, 2013 @11:38AM (#6749558)
Creativity (and carlsen is a big creativity player in the early game) doesn't really matter as long as the computer is strong enough to explore most, if not all game branches in the end game 20 moves deep. A really good player can only hope to draw.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by petegrif on Sunday November 17, 2013 @12:29PM (#6749759)
Hard to see what it could mean. And even if some genius came up with some currently inconceivable insight that could also be added to the computer's repetoire.
Re:Magnus Carlsen wins Game 6; leads Viswanathan Anand 4-2 by werid on Sunday November 17, 2013 @01:52PM (#6750218)
According to interviews with the people around him, he's not interested in beating machines.