News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reaching for Silicon Valley by rayiner on Saturday November 16, 2013 @06:25PM (#6746813)
The analysis is a bit off in a way that's relevant to the narrative. At least when I was there, nobody at GT had Stanford on their radar. Georgia Tech is a Big Industry kind of place. The perceived competitor is MIT, not Stanford. The traditional engineering fields (chemical, mechanical, aerospace) dominate and the links to industry are places like Lockheed or Boeing, not Google or Yahoo. The net result is that GT is a conservative and somewhat bureaucratic sort of place. Unsurprisingly, the administration had a hard time with someone who played fast and loose.
Re:Reaching for Silicon Valley by jfarmer on Saturday November 16, 2013 @06:56PM (#6746914)
I took the article to mean they were "reaching for Silicon Valley" in the sense that folks at the top (e.g., the Board of Regents or whomever is responsible for managing GT's endowment) were interested in establishing the kind of reputation for public/private collaboration that Stanford is known for, not necessarily that Stanford was constantly on the minds of Georgia Tech's students and faculty or that there was kind of "Stanford envy" at Georgia Tech.
Re:Reaching for Silicon Valley by rayiner on Saturday November 16, 2013 @10:09PM (#6747377)
My point is that even if the administration, understandably wants to model Stanford in ways, the students and faculty don't see Stanford or Silicon Valley as the model. The model is quite consciously MIT. It's a place where chairs are endowed by Boeing and Lockheed and getting a DARPA grant is more on people's minds than getting VC funding. Those affinities with traditional Big Industry drive the culture at GT.
Re:Reaching for Silicon Valley by larrys on Saturday November 16, 2013 @07:21PM (#6746985)
The article title appears to be a clear attempt to bait people into reading by making some connection to silicon valley.

Mention of Silicon Valley comes way down in the article and the point they almost seem to be making is how whatever was done wrong wouldn't have been a problem if GT was more like Stanford.

In any case try and think of what the title of the article would be if not the one listed? "Academic at Georgia Tech's house raided?"

Re:Reaching for Silicon Valley by loarabia on Saturday November 16, 2013 @10:53PM (#6747493)
I tend to agree with your point that the title is bad. Techmeme has the same article on their front page and the title is: "Case of Georgia Tech professor illustrates risks in taking university research commercial" which pretty accurate.
Re:Reaching for Silicon Valley by mjn on Saturday November 16, 2013 @06:35PM (#6746849)
I agree, and I think that's true with startup / spinoff ambitions as well. The perceived peers aren't really Stanford+Valley, but rather the clusters of engineering/biotech/etc. spinoffs that top engineering schools accumulate (UT, UIUC, MIT, etc.). Those tend to have less of a "do whatever you want" view, and more of a view that spinoffs are good, but need to take place within a set of rules that ensures that public money and payroll isn't being abused.