News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Internet architects propose encrypting all the world's we... by Silhouette on Saturday November 16, 2013 @06:13AM (#6744423)
It doesn't stop 3-letter agencies (though really, people should stop pretending that's where the real threat lies for most people) and it doesn't stop informed hackers or intrusive corporate firewalls.

It doesn't stop any organisation capable of compromising your certification chain.

That might be a TLA going after a root CA. We could debate the ethics of that but I'm not sure it's helpful for this discussion to go over all of that again.

It might be an "intrusive corporate firewall", but if you're doing anything personal and sensitive from work equipment then I'm somewhat lacking in sympathy. No doubt that equipment was provided to help you do your job, and it is quite possible that your employer has statutory and/or regulatory obligations to meet regarding controlling of data and auditing of same, which is probably what any intrusive scanning on the way out is for. As for scanning on the way in, you only have to look at how many idiots open any e-mail attachment even if it's under a neon sign saying "Trojan here!" and how many people try to use things like personal webmail over HTTPS from work computers, and you can see a strong argument for inspection as far as corporate IT is concerned. (I do think it is in the interests of all concerned for employees to be properly informed of the possibility that their "encrypted" communications aren't and any legitimate justifications that apply, though. A throwaway line about monitoring communications on page 17 of the contract is not a good way to build trust, IMHO.)

But how exactly is an "informed hacker" going to compromise something like your on-line banking if it's encrypted this way? Probably the biggest practical benefit of current HTTPS implementations is that they do stop Little Johnny Wireshark spying on everyone else in the cafe or Little Johnny ISP monitoring the private communications of his customers. Even if the chain of trust is compromised and someone has the encryption keys, it's still only that one party who can intercept your communications, and you're still guarding against monitoring across the rest of an untrusted network.

There are no comments on this comment yet.