Sometimes military development advances technologies in ways that might not have happened otherwise but it's hard to compare to the way development would have gone otherwise. Take the development of aircraft from their invention through WWII. Unquestionably there was a rapid pace of development during, and due to, WWI and WWII. But there was also a rapid pace of development outside of the wars. The design of the iconic WWII fighters the Supermarine Spitfire and P51 Mustang owe much to the advancement of high performance aviation spurred by the entirely civilian Schneider Trophy competitions through the 1920s and '30s, for example.
http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_computing_hardware
You're arguing there's an interplay between the public and private sector. That's true. But you would be hard-pressed to find an example of a major core tech that developed independently of significant government investment -- particularly in the highest-risk, most capital-intensive stuff. And that's why Hyperloop doesn't get funded.
I'm not sure about the history, but perhaps the internal combustion engine?
More generally, the line of reasoning in this thread assumes "this is how things have happened" to imply "this is the _only_ way things can happen". It is entirely conceivable that the private sector would, in the absense of government funding, step up and perform/fund fundamental research. But, in the current fiscal climate where there is still, generally speaking, copious government funding available (e.g., to the military), why would a private group spend money to do that when they can let someone else (the government) take the risk (with someone else's money).
http://www.longviewinstitute.org/projects/marketfundamentali...
Need I really demonstrate the fault in that logic?
Two examples:
1.Talk to people in the medical device community. There are plenty of good ideas , but they are hard to build and it's hard to raise money.[2]
2.Robotics: VC investments totaled in only $190 million in 2012[1] for a technology that is quite highly developed.
[1]http://www.hizook.com/blog/2013/06/10/venture-capital-vc-fun...
[2]This is partly due to the difficulty of writing software in this highly regulated environment. Seems like some pre approved platform should help here.
The robotics world is getting there but it's hardware so it takes longer and is more risky and with less room for pivots.
But sure, legislation could help immensely.
Unfortunately, this is the way the ecosystem is at the minute and we can only hope that when the bubble bursts the people that have made exits from these types of startups can invest or found & fund real innovation themselves.
Previously, it was common knowledge among the left, like Chomsky. (http://books.google.com/books?id=3VtILDSrZ7wC&pg=PA173&lpg=P...) Economic ideology is the religion of the age, where people are unable to see clear answers.
No, taxpayers do. Without consent. Government takes money from taxpayers and pays for those long-term things regardless of whether they agree with those things or not. Democracy and elections isn't consent - may I remind you that congress approval rating is now below 10%.
Well, given the degree to which spending exceed tax revenue, marginal changes in government expenses are actually paid for by bond purchasers, not taxpayers.
1. Government pays for really big long-term high-risk core technology development. Things like microprocessors, the internet, voice analysis, lasers, space rockets, highways, etc.
2. These are mostly done under the rubric of defense spending. (This is important.)
3. Private sector steps in to commercialize the projects that bear fruit.
Hyperloop falls under category #1. Those projects take billions invested over decades with very uncertain prospects. Usually supported by military procurement. Yes, even highways were built ostensibly for the military. And Siri on your iPhone? Funded by the CIA.
That kind of Really Big Fundamental innovation is funded by the government. It's never been VCs. They focus on the "last mile".
Space X is a good example of that: bringing a foundation of core tech developed by NASA to market, adding commercial-oriented innovation on the scale of a few years and a couple hundred million from the private sector. But even at this stage, there's still many more hundreds of millions in government procurement (prepaid launch contracts).
The reason Hyperloops don't get funded is that the government doesn't have a military application (or pretext) for it.
Now we could go on to ask why Silicon Valley's megabucks foundation is military spending and not, say, direct government investment in sustainable public services. But then we get to some uncomfortable issues, like how the public might feel more entitled to the fruits of those investments. Whereas if core science and tech is seen as a kind of "military surplus", free or cheap for the taking, then the VC private sector gets to keep the profits from commercialization.