News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Car Mechanic Dreams Up a Tool to Ease Births by rayiner on Thursday November 14, 2013 @11:28PM (#6737753)
The problem with such comparisons is that high-risk pregnancies won't be planned for home birth to begin with. Also, in a hospital, a physician will be called in at the first sight of any complication, so midwives won't be attending births that go wrong.

A comprehensive study in Oregon found death rates 6-8x higher in home births than hospital births: https://olis.leg.state.or.us/liz/2013R1/Downloads/CommitteeM....

See also this meta-survey of the literature: http://www.ajog.org/article/S0002-9378(10)00671-X/abstract ("Less medical intervention during planned home birth is associated with a tripling of the neonatal mortality rate.").

Re:Car Mechanic Dreams Up a Tool to Ease Births by mtrimpe on Friday November 15, 2013 @03:15AM (#6738308)
For what it's worth, the Netherlands was well knowm for a long time because we defaulted to midwife supervised hone birth with effective escalation in case of complications.

Up until I think 10 or so years ago we had one of Europe's best delivery success rates with that.

After that it seems that hospital deliveries became a safer choice and we've had relatively bad percentages since then because we culturally still value home births highly.

Re:Car Mechanic Dreams Up a Tool to Ease Births by yetanotherphd on Friday November 15, 2013 @12:30AM (#6737903)
From the study's abstract:

"Studies of planned home births attended by registered midwives have been limited by incomplete data, nonrepresentative sampling, inadequate statistical power and the inability to exclude unplanned home births. We compared the outcomes of planned home births attended by midwives with those of planned hospital births attended by midwives or physicians."

and

"We included all planned home births ... and all planned hospital births meeting the eligibility requirements for home birth that were attended by the same cohort of midwives ... We also included a matched [my emphasis] sample of physician-attended planned hospital births (n = 5331)."

Re:Car Mechanic Dreams Up a Tool to Ease Births by pit on Thursday November 14, 2013 @11:56PM (#6737822)
Your first point is spot-on. Home births are bound to be statistically more successful because they are (usually) only planned for low-risk pregnancies.

However, the increased death rate in the Oregon study is

a) localized to that state, and b) attributed to an overabundance of uncertified midwives:

> But out-of-hospital births are not as safe as births in hospitals in Oregon, where many of them are attended by birth attendants who have not completed an educational curriculum designed to provide all the knowledge, skills and judgment needed by midwives who practice in any setting.

In other words, there are a lot of "birth attendants" practicing midwifery in Oregon who aren't necessarily CNMs (certified nurse-midwives) or CMs (certified midwives) -- which is perhaps closer to the barber acting as surgeon analogy.

EDIT: Here's a rebuttal to the Wax study: http://www.midwiferytoday.com/articles/ajog_response.asp