Re:IBM Offers ‘Jeopardy’ Winner Watson as Cloud Application ...
by JunkDNA on Thursday November 14, 2013 @09:05AM
(#6732295)
There is so much marketing around Watson and so little data. I feel like a broken record every time this comes up, but where are the peer-reviewed research papers with data showing Watson's superior utility in real world settings like hospitals?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:IBM Offers ‘Jeopardy’ Winner Watson as Cloud Application ...
by codingdave on Thursday November 14, 2013 @10:11AM
(#6732711)
Why do you expect IBM to hold back on marketing a product until someone has produced peer-reviewed research papers?
Watson IS marketing. Always has been. It is a way to show off IBM's capabilities, in order to improve their brand and their bottom line. So now they are trying to monetize it as a product. If it has some academic interest, that is just an added bonus, but not its core purpose.
This is just business in the corporate world, and there is no expectation of peer-reviewed research when selling software products.
Re:IBM Offers ‘Jeopardy’ Winner Watson as Cloud Application ...
by lincolnq on Thursday November 14, 2013 @09:21AM
(#6732390)
I don't quite understand why you're demanding this. As I see it, Watson is still pretty experimental and we're probably still learning what kind of stuff it's good or bad at. Why not build a few apps, throw it at hospitals or schools or other use cases, and see whether it actually helps anyone?
Basically, I feel like you're asking for peer-reviewed papers that show that Dropbox is a good way to share files. Nobody would write a paper about that. They would just try Dropbox.
Re:IBM Offers ‘Jeopardy’ Winner Watson as Cloud Application ...
by willis77 on Thursday November 14, 2013 @09:40AM
(#6732509)
A lot of the hype has been around using Watson as a medical decision support system, so yes, they do need peer-reviewed papers before "throwing it at hospitals". In medicine, you can't "see if it helps" without a controlled experiment. It's just too subtle to see when it's not helping, and also too late.