News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 14, 2013 @12:02AM (#6730639)
> Attempts to divine—or calculate—how fiscal decisions affect the economy rest on the “marginal propensity to consume,” the likelihood that if you put a dollar in someone’s hand, he will spend rather than save it.

Why are economists always so hung up on the concept of saving vs. spending, as though one is inherently better than the other?

Spending is good because it stimulates the economy -- if 1000 instances of Joe buy some new clothes then the clothing retailers can hire some new sales staff. Investing is good because it stimulates the economy -- if 1000 instances of Joe buy a share of stock then the availability of capital to create new small businesses increases and new small businesses create jobs.

It isn't about spending vs. saving, it's about whether the money goes to something productive or efficient or it goes to something harmful or inefficient. If a rich person gets more money and invests in small businesses, that's good. If a rich person gets more money and uses it to hoard precious metals, that's bad. If a poor person gets more money and uses it to buy books and go to college, that's good. If a poor person gets more money and uses it to buy cigarettes or to secure credit to buy an inefficient luxury SUV, that's bad.

It's not about saving vs. consumption. Unless someone is just stuffing cash into a mattress (which is bad and also stupid), "saving" is just consumption of investments, which is consumption by proxy when the invested-in entity spends the money. The question is whether the thing ultimately consumed is more beneficial than the alternative -- which is a question I can certainly see why economists like to avoid, because you practically can't answer it in the aggregate.

Here's a great example. The hypothesis is that rich people spend differently than poor people because they're rich, right? The fact that they have money allows them to act rationally because they can afford to make long-term investments. So, if the hypothesis is correct, lottery winners should behave like rich people, because their newfound wealth allows them to plan for the long term and stop making short term decisions just to keep food on the table. Reality? A majority of lottery winners go on to declare bankruptcy.

Because it's not about rich vs. poor. It's about what types of economic activity produce beneficial results. But economists and governments are preposterously bad at predicting what those things will be.

Which means I'm going to be back in here beating the drum on the basic income. It provides the poor with a baseline level of consumption which they can choose of their own free will. The problem with need-based programs is that the government is deciding what people need, and they're terrible at it -- and then they create an enormous marginal tax rate on the poor by withdrawing the benefits from anyone who dares to live the life of luxury that exists just above the poverty line.

Let the people themselves decide what they need. People in the aggregate are smarter than legislators.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by dragonwriter on Thursday November 14, 2013 @12:18AM (#6730694)
> Why are economists always so hung up on the concept of saving vs. spending, as though one is inherently better than the other?

Generally, it has nothing to do with normative evaluations of what is better, it has to do with modelling how systems behave, and spending vs. saving are important difference in behavior with substantial effects within the economy (whether the effects of one or the other are better -- whether generally or in some particular circumstances -- than the effects of the other is a separate discussion, the import thing for the science of economics is that the two are significant, and different, and modelling the difference is therefore important to modelling the behavior of the economy in different circumstances.)

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by nhaehnle on Thursday November 14, 2013 @03:46AM (#6731314)
The question you lead with may answer itself once you clearly distinguish between "saving" and "investing" -- you muddle those terms up quite a bit in your comment.

Saving decisions by households primarily mean less spending, hence less demand, hence less incentive to invest in the first place. This is a plain common sense first order effect.

That there may be a second order effect via interest rates is somewhat plausible, but it just boggles the mind how many people seem to believe that this second order effect would ever trump the first order effect of savings decisions. And I think this is explained by the simple fact that people do not correctly distinguish between savings decisions and investment decisions, where I mean investment not in the sense of "buy some shares/funds", but in the sense of "create new means of production".

Just like it has been said that physics is understood through the search of the correct sign, it seems that economics is understood through the search of proper definitions of what we mean by "saving" and "investment".

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 14, 2013 @12:50PM (#6733889)
> That there may be a second order effect via interest rates is somewhat plausible, but it just boggles the mind how many people seem to believe that this second order effect would ever trump the first order effect of savings decisions.

This is just what I'm talking about. Dismissing the economic benefits of increased investment as "second order effects" when what really matters is whether the recipients of the money make more economically productive decisions than would the consumers in the alternative.

Take the obvious example. On the one hand you can invest money in a local small business which would otherwise not have had an investor and will use the money to hire more local employees who will go on to pay local taxes (allowing lower tax rates or more local services) and consume further local goods and services. On the other hand, you can go to Walmart and buy some knickknacks from China, which will do very little for the local economy as the primary result will be to stimulate the economy in China. It seems exceedingly obvious that the investment can be better for the local or national economy than the consumption. On the other hand, you can easily imagine some investment choice that would be less beneficial than some consumption choice -- because what matters is not the distinction between savings or investment and consumption, it is the economic benefit to the local economy of the ultimate use of the money.

> investment not in the sense of "buy some shares/funds", but in the sense of "create new means of production".

That distinction is certainly important, but that's exactly what I'm talking about. If you buy some shares, now the person who sold them has the money. So what does that person do with it? Perhaps they immediately turn around and buy some shares in something else. Now that seller has the money, and so on until somebody does something with it other than buying shares. So what is that? It could be something useful, like some economically productive type of consumption, or increasing the means of production. It could be something stupid, like hoarding gold or sticking it in a mattress or buying a prime piece of real estate and then not using it for anything. But these are the same decisions that the original party faced, and there is no reason to expect that the seller(s) of the shares will be any better or worse at finding a productive use of the money than the original party would have been.

Let's even go ahead and concede that on average savings are less economically productive than spending for some reason. You still have the same problem, because averages are not instances. There remain many instances of saving or investment that are more economically productive than many instances of spending, and preferring the latter to the former is conceding an enormous amount of economic inefficiency.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by nhaehnle on Thursday November 14, 2013 @01:52PM (#6734514)
In many cases there is no recipient of the money because we're talking about the bottom 80% in terms of wealth who typically just end up leaving the money in some form of savings account or paying down some debt.

That is probably a wise decision for that individual, but it's not going to boost the economy.

Your obvious example may be obvious to you, but it is not a typical example of savings decisions. That was my point: You have to distinguish clearly between savings decisions and investment decisions. Also, typical cases and averages are what matters when you look at the macroeconomy, and that's what you were talking about in your first comment to which I replied.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by AnthonyMouse on Saturday November 16, 2013 @08:57PM (#6747196)
> In many cases there is no recipient of the money because we're talking about the bottom 80% in terms of wealth who typically just end up leaving the money in some form of savings account or paying down some debt.

How do you mean there is no recipient? In that case the recipient is the lender or the bank, which allows them to lend the money to someone else.

You might also be surprised how good for the economy paying down debts can be in the long term. The person who paid the debt is not paying interest on it anymore, and has now improved their credit worthiness, which reduces the interest they pay on all of their remaining debts. The interest not paid can be spent or used to pay further debts (virtuous cycle). Or in the future the borrower can leverage the increased credit worthiness into more borrowing at lower monthly payments, allowing increased future spending.

This is really one of those situations where politics and reality collide. Having the middle class pay down their debts is great for the economy in the long-term. But it may not do anything much today, which is what politicians care about when they're running to reelection. Hence we have a bunch of backward-facing policies that prioritize spending over saving when they are both important to economic growth and the choices between one and the other would be more efficiently made by the people.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by nhaehnle on Monday November 18, 2013 @11:23AM (#6755023)
When you pay down bank debt, the money just disappears, hence no recipient.

Similarly, if you save money at your bank, your bank doesn't actually get more money. At best, you're shifting it from a checking account to a savings account.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by thaumasiotes on Thursday November 14, 2013 @04:56AM (#6731523)
> The hypothesis is that rich people spend differently than poor people because they're rich, right?

I would never have guessed that. There's a longstanding line of thought that says rich people are rich because they spend differently than poor people (obviously, I'm simplifying). A finding that rich people and poor people spend differently does nothing to reverse the form of the argument.

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 14, 2013 @12:59PM (#6733997)
It certainly goes a long way to explaining the persistence of generational poverty, and pointing to a necessary prerequisite to solving it. You need to do more than supply money or opportunities, you need to gradually change ingrained behavior so that opportunities can be capitalized on rather than burned for warmth.
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by fulafel on Thursday November 14, 2013 @04:22AM (#6731437)
> Why are economists always so hung up on the concept of saving vs. spending, as though one is inherently better than the other?

Because effecting changes in aggregate saving vs spending is one main thing that policymakers use for regulating the economy (to counter overheating or depression).

Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by jotm on Thursday November 14, 2013 @04:12AM (#6731402)
But the rich guy hoarding metals is also funding other businesses (the mining companies), as does the guy buying the SUV and cigarettes. Everything is effective spending, while saving kinda slows that down.
Re:Economists Discover the Poor Behave Differently From the ... by AnthonyMouse on Thursday November 14, 2013 @01:01PM (#6734018)
The guy who buys cigarettes is making business for his future oncologist too. But fooling yourself into thinking that this is economically productive is the broken window fallacy.