News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Are you more likely to cast the deciding vote or die on y... by Cogito on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @08:55PM (#6730035)
Regardless of any other arguments against this idea, I think that the key implied proposition is false; that there are other brains 'similar enough' to your own to share the same physical processes is extremely unlikely.

There are more possible configurations of the neurons in your brain than there are atoms in the universe. Even worse, the future excited state of your brain depends on the current excited state of your brain.

In order for the decision you make to be correlated to the decision of someone else's brain you almost certainly need to work at quite a few abstractions above the physical one.

This comment is getting longer than I meant, but an interesting counter point to my previous statement would be that many brains will react in similar ways to the same stimulus, and this may be put down to a 'physical process'. An example might be reactions to attractive people.

Re:Are you more likely to cast the deciding vote or die on y... by Peaker on Thursday November 14, 2013 @07:15AM (#6731860)
I agree with most of what you are saying.

The similarity is definitely not a physical one at an atomic level, but indeed at a very high level of abstraction.

If we compare two computers running the same algorithm, one could be ARM, one could be using vacuum tubes. But if at a high-level of abstraction, they are running the same algorithm on the same inputs, they will yield identical results and not independent results.

Similarly, I think the "algorithms" in our brains are very similar (or even identical) at some high level of abstraction.