Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by ethomson on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:53PM
(#6721485)
Of course we're competing. That's the whole point of a merit-based bonus system. What's your counterargument?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by michaelt on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @06:42PM
(#6722266)
Generating value for your employer is not a zero-sum game. If I make the company an extra $x and the company rewards me with a bonus of $0.1x that money doesn't have to come from the guy next to me, it comes from the extra $x I brought into the company.
The idea that "there's a fixed budget for raises" or "that money goes into a different pot" is simply a way of refusing while transferring blame to an inanimate object.
Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by marshray on Wednesday November 13, 2013 @02:47AM
(#6723921)
Even if the reality is that there is a fixed budget for raises that needs to be awarded fairly, it doesn't logically imply there should be a fixed number of 'excellent' and 'awful' employee reviews to be handed out.
Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by mhurron on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @05:12PM
(#6721630)
When one person succeeds we all succeed breaks down when you are pushed to succeed at the expense of everyone else. You are supposed to be working for the good of the whole, not just yourself.
Cooperation and team work are also meritorious, but they are not rewarded or encouraged in this type of merit-based system.
Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by ethomson on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @05:37PM
(#6721862)
I agree with you, but this doesn't address the clever and glib but ultimately content-free argument above. You can stack rank on any criteria - including cooperation and team work.
Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by jacques_chester on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @08:04PM
(#6722654)
You're handwaving away the problem of measuring intangibles.
Re:Microsoft does away with stack ranking
by Ensorceled on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @09:24PM
(#6722939)
It should not be a zero sum game. I attempt to pay my team based upon what they are worth to the company; not how they rank compared to their co-workers. You should be able to have an entire team of #1 developers ...