Statically, yes. However I'm having a harder time mentally analyzing what this would do dynamically, which is a much more interesting problem, since the real world is not static.
My first approximation is that because "everyone" would know this is something they can do with their debt, that lending would consequently become much more rare, and lenders would be much more careful about securing their loans. The initial impact on the economy would probably be sharply negative; what happens after that is probably a "your guess is as good as mine" situation, even amongst economists. Attitudes about debt have varied widely throughout time and space. Some will say tightened lending will wreck the economy longterm, others would suggest that loose lending has already wrecked the economy and the initial shock would simply be paying down damage already done, after which the economy would be much healthier. Which side you fall down on probably has more to do with ideology than education; given how much trouble economists have explaining even our current economy I'm not willing to give even experts much credence for explaining how such a different one would work.
Changes beget other changes and so on. Finding the steady state level of change would be challenging yet interesting to model.
One reason why many of the the "crazy" ideas posted on HN don't make it to policy, is that there are people trained in economics who are able to see the flaws in such policies.
EDIT: and in case you were curious, this wouldn't generally be considered a dynamic problem in economics. Once the policy was announced, interest rates would immediately change to a new equilibrium, which accounted for people's higher tendency to default. So the problem is simply to calculate the new static equilibrium.
Anyway it seems like messing with debt contracts is a bad way to change the interest rate, if that's all you want to do, since that is precisely the lever that the Federal Reserve controls anyway.
Doesn't valuing your credit counteract that incentive? You'd only get one shot at this before you lose it. Also, this has long been an option with credit cards.
So what? All poor credit means is that it will be more expensive for me to borrow in the future. If I know I can buy back my debt for pennies on the dollar, who cares how expensive it is for me to borrow?
What this would do is make credit an essentially all or nothing proposition. One screw up and any future car loan, student loan, mortgage or other debt I want is out. I would rather have the opportunity to make up for my mistake by borrowing more expensivly than never being allowed to borrow again.
I'd see loans more as band aid for broken social structure: "People would not be able to pay for their important medical bills in case of crises." - If the US had a proper medical care system nobody would have to pay for important treatment personally, "Without student loans only the rich would be able to go to university" - If good education was free (at least until your first master degree) even more people from poor families would dare to get advanced degrees, and so on.
There are a lot of countries in which a debt free life is the norm and not the exception. The only parts of society where loans are necessary seems to be for startups and generally for corporate investments.
A creditor needs only say 5% a year return and will be willing to lend. I may need money now to buy a new computer or repair my car which has value greater to me than the 5% my creditor values if my car/computer allows me to work effectively or even work in the first place.
Countries without broken social structure such as Sweden and Norway also high debt to income ratios. Debt is not about having to pay for things that we think the state should pay, its strictly about our consumption patterns. And some of us debt finance high value items such as education and some of us debt finance lifestyle increases. http://www.norges-bank.no/pages/93708/Staff_memo_2013_05_eng...
Life style improvements - such as getting a better car, or going on holidays, or bigger tv etc, do are not improvements to your cashflow, and should never be financed by debt.
Then, when they are 18, they'd have a much more mature mentality, and won't go out to get drunk and cause problems for themselves. They'd be able to get a job, or try start their own business, etc. When time comes for them to have their own kids, they'd have enough to take their kids to disneyland.
The problem is that people just go to collections without trying to collect the debt.
They can and do make direct discounted offers to the debtor; but these are completely different offers than sales to debt collectors; it is not in their interest to match the offers.
You mean free tuition for all like we used to have?
Also, if you are Scottish and attending a Scottish university tuition fees are still paid by the taxpayer as they did in the old days. (NB I am a Scot and I've never understood how this can be justified).
Creditors asses your potential for default and base the rate of lending on that risk. In your scenario the rate of default would always be high therefore the rate that you borrow at would be extremely high, think loan shark high. Or you would find that no one is willing to lend money and this would cripple an important part of the financial system. Think student loans never existing.