News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @12:43PM (#6719334)
I know it will be a wildly unpopular question to ask but, after his own history at the helm of Microsoft, where he made most of the money he's using now, can we trust him?

Is there a way we can be sure his donations (and the donations of people and companies that decide to donate because he is doing so) are not furthering his own agenda and creating a market for the companies he invests in? Even if they are beneficial to the affected populations, can we call that philanthropy?

Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can... by sparkie on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:37PM (#6719809)
While he claims he is a devout fan of capitalism, he fails to address the capitalist role in sustaining poverty and warfare. Africa is still completely colonized by the IMF and World Bank, whose policies over the past half century have forced its nations to take loans they can't repay, and as a result, they are forced to sell under-priced foods. This food is then largely wasted in developed countries where Capitalism commands that people consume more than they need to survive. At the apex of the Capitalist market is the arms industry, selling weapons to tin-pot dictators in African nations which have the opposite effect and only serve to increase poverty and suffering.

Meanwhile, Gates attends "private clubs" full of the men who run these banks, are shareholders in those same arms companies and who dictate the foreign policy of the developed nations. (e.g. Bilderberg 2010)

If not disingenuous to the point of turning your stomach, he is just naive and sees the world through a very narrow scope. I suspect it's a bit of both.

Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can... by ef4 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:07PM (#6719515)
> Even if they are beneficial to the affected populations, can we call that philanthropy?

This is just silly zero-sum thinking. Obviously ending world poverty is hugely beneficial to anyone who can sell things to those newly enriched people. But that doesn't make it "not philanthropy".

Even if he's really thinking "let's save 10 million children from dying of malaria so some of them will buy Windows phones" (which is silly), that's still fine by me. What matters are outcomes, not motives.

Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can... by rbanffy on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @02:19PM (#6720187)
> Even if he's really thinking "let's save 10 million children from dying of malaria so some of them will buy Windows phones"

It's more like "let's donate 10% of the money needed to save 10 million children so others can donate the 90% needed to finish developing my vaccine and test it on the kids".

Or something like it.

> What matters are outcomes, not motives.

We have to be careful about that. The most obvious are not necessarily the only outcomes, nor the most relevant and lasting.

Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can... by Lucy_karpova on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:49PM (#6720918)
I completely agree. The whole article seems to be a mix of what people would like to hear re philanthropy and what Bill Gates would like other people to do. Not sure he tells out all the motives he has. But the main idea of the article is good –getting hands on helping the world but doing what you can do the best is cool. What many idealists who work in this area lack is co-working with those who can help them use cutting edge technologies and get reasonable funding. The ideas are great, let’s see what the implementation will be like. And is the Gates foundation the only one that does that?
Re:Bill Gates: My Plan to Improve Our World, and How You Can... by eaurouge on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:06PM (#6721088)
Is there a way we can be sure his donations (and the donations of people and companies that decide to donate because he is doing so) are not furthering his own agenda and creating a market for the companies he invests in? Even if they are beneficial to the affected populations, can we call that philanthropy?

You mean, does he hope to make back hundreds of billions of dollars from the tens of billions of dollars he is giving away? He currently owns less than 5% of Microsoft, and on schedule to own even less (possibly none) in 5 years. You're suggesting that Bill Gates is such a skilled investor that his investment of well over $30B will earn him huge profits from his portfolio of stock investments, preferably before he dies?

I know it will be a wildly unpopular question to ask but, after his own history at the helm of Microsoft, where he made most of the money he's using now, can we trust him?

You make it sound as if he made his money by selling babies. I know Bill Gates was a ruthless entrepreneur, with questionable ethical practices. But what did he do at Microsoft to make you think he's incapable of doing good for doing good's sake?