News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by brudgers on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:14AM (#6718226)
As an exercise, it's an interesting project. As a product, "better than Google docs" is not getting anyone anything - [Microsoft hatred aside] that space is where Excel lives. And as always, Microsoft is eliminating any of Google's potential advantages systematically.

After nearly 40 years of commercial spreadsheets, the empirical evidence is that spreadsheets are hard, otherwise there would be more of them. And the reason Excel dominates is because they get so many of the non-trivial details right.

Example: consider how often inaccuracy of JavaScript floating point operations makes a blog post appearance on the web [I recall several even on HN] versus the rarity of similar observations regarding Excel calculations. Then consider how many complicated floating point ops are done via Excel functions every minute of every day by non-computer scientists and non-programmers.

A couple of years ago I came to the conclusion that Excel, not Windows, is the killer-app for Microsoft, and that Microsoft knows it and invests in it accordingly. The person who decides on office suites is the manager who uses spreadsheets not the people using the word processor [in which case we would talk about WordPerfect not MS Word as the standard].

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by gotofritz on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @11:05AM (#6718531)
The UI of Google spreadsheet works much better than Excel (not to mention OpenOffice). No such nonsense as, for example, you can only paste something you copied once.

The reason Google Spreadsheet hasn't taken off is lack of investment on Google's part, which is needed because from what I understand from some Google's devs comments, it is a right mess under the bonnet.

We can only guess why Google haven't invested in it, maybe they don't believe people are willing to share their private or corporate data with Google's, or they think the potential for disaster is too high.

But I believe the potential is there

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by brudgers on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @12:47PM (#6719362)
The reason I've been thinking about spreadsheets is because of the potential.

I suspect the reason for Google's lack of investment is the degree of difficulty which it takes to develop a spreadsheet that can compete with Excel on something other than price. The world is littered with trivial attempts at spreadsheets, from Emacs org-mode tables and calc-mode to Common-Lisp's Cells project to Scheme-in-a-grid.

As I skim and wade and slog about Knuth's Semi-Numerical Algorithms, I get the feeling that any useful spreadsheet is probably going to have a bit of the "Electric components by Lucas" about it in order to bash a numerical implementation sufficiently to meet the reasonable expectations of real world non-programmer end-users. You won't get far with the CEO of a Fortune 500 corporation by saying, "Sometimes addition and multiplication are non-associative, so be sure to avoid cumulative rounding errors."

Pasting: See Office Clipboard. http://office.microsoft.com/en-us/word-help/copy-and-paste-m...

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by tanzam75 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @12:40PM (#6719312)
> The UI of Google spreadsheet works much better than Excel (not to mention OpenOffice). No such nonsense as, for example, you can only paste something you copied once.

I'm not seeing this.

You can indeed paste from the clipboard multiple times in Excel. I just tried this, and it works fine in both Excel 2013 and the Excel web app.

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by kubiiii on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:45PM (#6720892)
Yes but you can't paste anymore if you do anything else between copying and pasting. On 2010 at least.
Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by pessimizer on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @11:15AM (#6718606)
I think that the empirical evidence shows that spreadsheets are hard to learn, and that unless people can take their hard-won knowledge to a new product, they aren't going to switch. Or that there are a lot of other types of software where you can make money but don't have to compete with the MS Office monopoly. Or, maybe, the empirical evidence hasn't shown anything conclusively about spreadsheets that it hasn't shown about word processing, presentations, web browsers, or photo editing: if you're the legacy brand of a complex industry standard, you have to be really awful not to own the market just based on your own inertia and deep pockets.

>the rarity of similar observations regarding Excel calculations.

There is no rarity of these: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Numeric_precision_in_Microsoft...

>Excel, not Windows, is the killer-app for Microsoft

Agreed:)

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by brudgers on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @01:01PM (#6719479)
For more than a decade, Lotus123 was probably more dominate in the spreadsheet business than Excel is today.

The thing about Excel is it's good enough to compete with free, e.g. Google Docs and OpenOffice/OfficeLibre. That's perhaps why Microsoft Excel buried less expensive competitors with approximately equivalent functionality for a typical user, not only Lotus123 but also Quattro Pro.

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by revorad on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @11:08AM (#6718556)
We're not expecting to steal any die-hard fans away from Excel. We couldn't possibly pry Excel from their cold dead hands :)

From the signups so far, it appears there are plenty of people looking for an alternative, so we'll focus on satisfying them.

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by username42 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:41AM (#6718389)
I do not know what you mean by "Microsoft knows it and invests in it accordingly". For me, the big quality of Excel is that it has almost not changed in 20 years. If Microsoft changes anything in excel, this will hurt millions of users.
Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by tanzam75 on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @12:48PM (#6719370)
> I do not know what you mean by "Microsoft knows it and invests in it accordingly". For me, the big quality of Excel is that it has almost not changed in 20 years. If Microsoft changes anything in excel, this will hurt millions of users.

Microsoft has changed lots of things in Excel. The pivot tables and graphs were rewritten in 2007. The statistics functions were rewritten in 2010. These are pretty fundamental features.

The key is that they made these changes by versioning. v1 Pivot Tables are not automatically converted to v2 Pivot Tables. The new statistics functions have new names -- the old statistics functions are still around. This ensures bug-for-bug compatibility with old spreadsheets.

Re:I'm tired of waiting for Google spreadsheets, so I'm buil... by Arnor on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @10:32AM (#6718333)
Sounds like someone who should be involved in the beta test to me.