News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by pkaler on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:17AM (#6716466)
Except that Google does the exact same thing with Google Play Services on Android. Ask Skyhook. On top of that, Google keeps pushing organic SERP listings further and further down the page to push people to Google+.

We actually live in much better times than the Microsoft monopoly days. Apple, Google, Amazon, Facebook have asymmetric business models. Consumers benefit in the long run as they all battle each other.

Apple doesn't have to monetize Maps so they can chip away at Google's ad revenue. Google doesn't have to monetize Android OS and devices so they can chip away at Apple's hardware/software revenue.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by quadrangle on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:29AM (#6716499)
Apple is accused of being criminal. So showing that Google does the same thing is a refutation?

If Bank of America illegally forecloses on people, it's okay because Citibank does that too?

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by netcan on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @05:22AM (#6716909)
"So showing that Google does the same thing is a refutation?" - genuinely interesting question.

Do common law principle apply in some way here? IE, assuming there is no legal precedent, is the lack of litigation elsewhere relevant?

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by nknighthb on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:35AM (#6716531)
Apple is not being accused of being criminal by anyone who understands antitrust law. The proof is the comparison to Microsoft, an entity that held a clear monopoly where Apple does not.
Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by adventured on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:47AM (#6716570)
Modern anti-trust law is not about monopolies.

You can nearly count the number of substantial monopoly cases in US history on one hand.

However, take a look over the anti-trust cases just since 1994 (almost none of which have to do with monopolies):

http://www.justice.gov/atr/cases/index.html#page=page-1

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by nknighthb on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @05:31AM (#6716947)
I can tell you haven't read the indictments. If you had, you'd notice a common theme that A) matches the Apple/Amazon books case you brought up earlier, and B) very much does not match the Maps case.

The DOJ is concerned with suppression of competition on an industry level. Amazon/Apple arguably did so. Microsoft certainly did so. Two platforms in fierce competition, neither in a truly dominant market position, using their own Maps application, is not what the DOJ is going to worry about.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by uid on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:30AM (#6716728)
Oh, the irony.
Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by Doctor_Fegg on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:27AM (#6716493)
Indeed. Google pushes Google Maps as an unchangeable default just as much as Apple does, just not on Android.

iOS market share: 54% (or less, who you believe).

Google Search market share: 67%.

So when Google Search lets you replace Google Maps as the in-page default with Bing Maps/OpenStreetMap/whatever - you know, when you search for a city or zipcode - I'll start worrying about the iOS defaults.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by cromwellian on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:34AM (#6716524)
Please explain how that's technically going to work. You're talking about federating the huge Google search query volume out to third party sites, which have to respond typically in just a few dozen milliseconds, and have to work with Google Instant and Google Suggest without significantly adding to user interface delay.

At best, you could stick an <IFRAME> in the page and point it at a user configured maps site, only you don't know if it is going to return a maps result. What if the query isn't for a location? Or what if the user's third party map supplier doesn't have the location? Then you get a big empty <IFRAME> with nothing in it, and a bad user experience. You'd also increase the perception that the Google search results are slow because it would take longer for the page to finish loading.

Allowing pluggable providers on the client for launching URL intents makes sense, I don't think it makes as much sense for search engines to federate queries in this way, there are much more difficult performance and privacy issues with such a model.

The Portal/Portlet model of "search" has been tried before and users didn't really like the experience.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by Doctor_Fegg on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:48AM (#6716574)
It's not that hard. If Google still does the geocoding, then an iframe with a call to bing.com/maps/google?lat=1.2&lon=3.4 works fine.
Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by cromwellian on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:00AM (#6716618)
That will display a map, but it won't display the local business listings which is part and parcel of Google's Knowledge-Graph driven maps listings. Also, the <IFRAME> will add non-trivial amounts of latency to the page display.

When you type in something that generates a map these days, you get Knowledge Graph entries, Maps, Related places and people, and a bunch of other ancillary things. How can Google simultaneously iterate and evolve their search, and at the same time, provided a fixed API for federating this stuff?

This is one of those things that works much better in theory than in practice. I'd rather Google federate social and login before messing with search answers.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by Doctor_Fegg on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:08AM (#6716638)
Sure, but you're assuming that I want Google-like results. I don't. I don't really want Knowledge Graph-driven business listings. I just want a map which shows roads in different colours rather than all-white (and a host of other cartographic howlers) which Google doesn't currently offer me.

But hearing "our way or the highway" coming from a Googler is making the argument for me to try DDG again, so thanks. :)

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by cromwellian on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:33AM (#6716740)
First, I don't work on Search, I work on open-source stuff, and this is just my private opinion.

Secondly, I am for the idea in theory, I just don't think it is practical to do in a way that adds a lot of value. You also have to worry about the legal/privacy ramifications of funneling everyone's queries out to third party providers, I'm pretty sure that would cause a large blowup.

Third, there were already services that sort of did what you ask, for example, MetaCrawler, which was around way before DDG, would federate out queries to multiple search engines and combine the results. It wasn't very pretty.

I'm not sure IFRAMEd results really add that much value for a user, but one could easily conduct the experiment by making a Chrome/Firefox extension that replaces Google Maps results with OpenMaps.

In an ideal world, one wouldn't need fleets of cars and people to make maps databases. There's be some kind of standard, like http://acme.org/geo.json or maybe KML where crawlers would crawl the web to get accurate business listings, indoor maps, photos, menus, hours of operation, and other stuff. And then anyone could write a little bit of JS that could be registered with the browser like <link rel="geopanel" href="geopanel-fancy.js" type="application/business-data">, and when Google or Bing when to show a business listing, they'd just need to output the json record, and any registered providers could render it.

I'd be all in favor of a fully federated world, I'd spoken about it at length in the past (http://timepedia.blogspot.com/2008/05/decentralizing-web.htm...)

But I think one has to be realistic that the the fully open, federated solutions often do not compete favorably with vertically integrated solutions from a user experience point of view. They often can only do so once the underlying features have been fully commoditized.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by hahainternet on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @05:00AM (#6716828)
> But hearing "our way or the highway" coming from a Googler is making the argument for me to try DDG again, so thanks. :)

So yeah, trolling then.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by ManAboutCouch on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @04:42AM (#6716767)
The problem with the iframe approach is that Google's geocoding service TOS explicitly states that the output of the geocode operation can only be displayed on a Google map.

Google's geocoding service is underpinned by a lot of third party datasets which would have to be (very expensively) relicensed if Google started passing the results out to maps under the control of other organisations.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by sdoering on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:33AM (#6716520)
Could you explain, what your argument does to the discussion? I mean, if on my desktop/laptop I am feed up with Google Maps in SERPs, I can use Bing or DDG or whatever.

On iOS (and maybe on Android) not that much.

Your argument should have been: Imagine a world, where on your desktop on Windows you can only use Bing Maps. Then your argument might have been valid.

Re:It is criminal that Apple gets away with not allowing alt... by Doctor_Fegg on Tuesday November 12, 2013 @03:43AM (#6716553)
It's about what you've "bought into".

I can't imagine switching away from Google Search. I've tried Bing, I've tried DuckDuckGo. I can't get used to them; the presentation of the results, the stuff I expect to be ranked highly. It's not that they're worse, it's just that I can't rewire a habit of years of searching in Google every day. I wish I could.

But I'm not particularly attached to either the iOS or Android ecosystem. I have an Android phone and an iPad. I could replace them with an iPhone and an Android tablet if I really wanted and I doubt I'd notice much difference.

So when you say "if I am fed up with Google Maps I can use Bing", that's a switch you can make, good for you. I find it harder than you to make the search engine switch, and easier than you to make the smartphone switch. Is that so hard to understand?