News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Devil Is in the Digits: Evidence That Iran's Election... by philwelch on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @07:25PM (#671332)
How does that follow? Would anyone worth consideration seriously believe this government is legitimate even if the election wasn't fixed? What sane person says, "oh, they've shot dozens of people to death and tried to cover it up, but at least they didn't rig an election"?

The regime had their chance to relent, and they only cracked down. It's not up to them anymore.

Re:The Devil Is in the Digits: Evidence That Iran's Election... by scott_s on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @07:50PM (#671351)
I believe you are interpreting what I'm saying in the wrong manner.

The Iranian government is autocratic and has probably abused its power to maintain that power. I take that as a given in any discussion of recent events. But that fact alone does not mean they will lose their power. Unfortunately, it probably is up to them, since they have most of the power in Iran.

In order for the Iranian government to lose its power, it must either relent and cede some power in the hopes of maintaining what some of what they have, or the Iranian people have to revolt. Both are more likely to happen if there is solid evidence that the election is rigged.

Re:The Devil Is in the Digits: Evidence That Iran's Election... by philwelch on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @10:51PM (#671498)
It's not so simple as you make it out to be. The Iranian government is a complex mix of democracy and theocracy. If enough mullahs and enough of the populace are turned against Khamenei and Ahmadinejad, Khamenei and Ahmadinejad will fall. The murder of Neda Agha-Soltan, and any murders that follow hers, will turn more mullahs and more common Iranians than a fixed election ever would. (Everyone thought the elections were fixed anyway. That's how Ahmadi got elected the first time--the reformists boycotted the election.)
Re:The Devil Is in the Digits: Evidence That Iran's Election... by scott_s on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @11:29PM (#671531)
I don't disagree with anything you said. But, if I understand you correctly, you don't think that demonstrably fixed elections would effect that complex mix at all. I think they would.

My simple rational is that you're going to have more support from the people and lower levels of the government if one can provide compelling evidence the elections were fixed. There's a difference between most people thinking the elections are fixed, and actually having evidence to support the conclusion. Such knowledge emboldens people.