News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Full Screen Mario Takedown Notice by krapp on Monday November 11, 2013 @10:53AM (#6712158)
They may legally have had no other options but to point and shoot, especially when it became clear that Full Screen Mario was popular, but IANAJL so I don't know.

I see your point, though i'd still contend Nintendo doesn't need eyeballs or goodwill when it comes to their flagship products. They can pretty much stick Link or Mario onto anything and it will still sell. You can play the original Mario officially on newer platforms. One of my favorite desk toys is a power-up mushroom I got from Hot Topic that had candy in it which I immediately poured into the trash because the thing it came in was so cool. The popularity of Full Screen Mario demonstrates that - people love Mario, especially the old 8-bit version. It's quite possible that Nintendo discovered there was a market to be tapped with browser-based games that they were unaware of (or unaware of the scale of), but they own Mario anyway, and they don't need to do Josh Goldberg any favors.

Although I completely agree that a great deal of potential creative value is being lost by not allowing classic games to be legally remade (I would love to take a crack at some Intellivision games, especially the old TSR adventures) that's an abstract issue. Nintendo's not an indie game factory that needs to build cred within the gaming community, and while the discussion about the value of derivative works and copyright is worth having, this outcome was pretty much a fait accompli.

Re:Full Screen Mario Takedown Notice by kamjam on Monday November 11, 2013 @09:40PM (#6715525)
While I agree with your point, and no one is disputing that Nintendo owns all rights to Mario and they may not need more visitors, goodwill is a difficult thing to earn. It's even easier to lose. Time will tell, but hopefully they will either take this or have their own dev team release something.

That fact is that this project is now public domain, it's right there on Github and any of us can take the source code and build it. Of course it's illegal to host it, but that doesn't mean that those more techincally inclined couldn't run the game locally.