Re:It's the Umami – Why the Truth About MSG is So Easy to Sw...
by not_clear on Monday November 11, 2013 @10:30AM
(#6712042)
Interesting - the metafilter referenced elsewhere on the thread had a pointer to a paper about D-glutamate vs L-glutamate. Apparently, bacterial fermentation generates a fair amount of D-glutamate, but this is true of "naturally occurring" fermentation (such as in cheese) too.
The abstract claims foods to which MSG is added directly contained lower amounts of D-glutamate than foods where the MSG comes from fermented foods. I wonder why? Maybe due to better optimization / control for L-glutamate production in the bacteria?
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1002/chir.530060410/ab...
Wikipedia confirms this
The referenced papers on the process (from 1957!) indicates that they were reporting L-glutamate producing bacteria specifically: Here is an overall history of MSG production, including chemical synthesis (now obsolete). Even when they were doing this, they screened out the D-glutamate and re-synthesized it to maximize L-glutamate production (might not have been 100% effective, as apparently it involved doing optical screening of the crystals) Disclaimer - I am Japanese American, so grew up with Ajinomoto MSG, dashi, tomato sauce, parmesan, Doritos, etc. as part of my diet, so am biased toward skepticism on this topic.