Re:Artificial-intelligence research revives its old ambitions
by eli_gottlieb on Sunday November 10, 2013 @06:00PM
(#6708873)
>Talking about infinity is a total red herring and you know that - especially because if your method of increasing intelligence is "search randomly" then an AI will not be able to make a better AI - all it can do is continue the random search humans already started.
Well the good approach that requires a halting oracle is AIXI, which uses semi-approximable (IIRC on the terminology) Solomonoff Induction hooked up to an expectimax tree.
So it does have to examine every possible "universe" as a Turing Machine, but it uses proven-convergent probabilistic reasoning to get rid of the bad ones and raise good hypotheses to the top much faster than a universal search.
>The speed of intelligence scales. But not the quality of it.
>
>The quality of intelligence is something very hard to quantify. But as simply as I can state it, it's the quality of coming up with an idea that is not just an extension of an existing one, but an idea that came seemingly from nowhere. To someone else the idea appears magic, and no amount of thinking by that other person can lead him in a path that will end up there.
To be frank, before I'll believe this I want to see studies done on either humans or a mathematical examination of formal models of intelligent agents.
I think "never" is much too strong a word, considering that we seem to have a huge abundance of people capable of learning calculus even though few can rediscover it from scratch. There appear to exist very many people who would require such great efforts to learn certain things that doing so would be unpractical, but very few who simply cannot learn things no matter how much effort they put in.
Well the good approach that requires a halting oracle is AIXI, which uses semi-approximable (IIRC on the terminology) Solomonoff Induction hooked up to an expectimax tree.
So it does have to examine every possible "universe" as a Turing Machine, but it uses proven-convergent probabilistic reasoning to get rid of the bad ones and raise good hypotheses to the top much faster than a universal search.
>The speed of intelligence scales. But not the quality of it. > >The quality of intelligence is something very hard to quantify. But as simply as I can state it, it's the quality of coming up with an idea that is not just an extension of an existing one, but an idea that came seemingly from nowhere. To someone else the idea appears magic, and no amount of thinking by that other person can lead him in a path that will end up there.
To be frank, before I'll believe this I want to see studies done on either humans or a mathematical examination of formal models of intelligent agents.
I think "never" is much too strong a word, considering that we seem to have a huge abundance of people capable of learning calculus even though few can rediscover it from scratch. There appear to exist very many people who would require such great efforts to learn certain things that doing so would be unpractical, but very few who simply cannot learn things no matter how much effort they put in.