News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Social Darwinism at the Soup Kitchen by jdminhbg on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @12:21PM (#670646)
"Examining the fortuitous circumstances that separate the haves and have nots is a scary endeavor. Why do we have the jobs and cars and apartments? Are we smarter? Maybe more educated, but not smarter. Harder working? Not a chance. Do we possess some specialized skill absent among the droves of desperate job seekers? Probably nothing that couldn't be learned within a couple weeks."

I think the appropriate cliche to insert here is "[citation needed]."

In fact, I'd take the entire article and flip it around on the author -- is the reason he needs to assert that it's mere circumstance that separates the homeless from the middle class that it's uncomfortable for him to confront the reality that many are not capable of living "normal" lives?

That's unfounded and it's unfair to pop-psychoanalyze a stranger, but it's exactly the same exercise he's engaging in. Not really insightful or relevant.

Re:Social Darwinism at the Soup Kitchen by Retric on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @01:25PM (#670759)
If you work with the homeless you find a large number of them have mental issues and or addictions. So you could just say it's their problem and move on.

But, it’s somewhat scary to think mental issues and addictions might be fairly random. The largest part of what separates you from being homeless could be random differences in your DNA, and who you happened to have for parents. Which you had zero controwl over.

Re:Social Darwinism at the Soup Kitchen by jdminhbg on Tuesday June 23, 2009 @02:14PM (#670862)
Yeah, I tried hard to word my comment to be the 'my company went under' kind of luck rather than the genetic lottery kind of luck, but I couldn't do it and be succinct.

If you see the quote I included, it's clear the author wants us to think the homeless are 'just like us,' but to me that seems dangerously counterproductive. If I were homeless, you could give me a laptop and wifi and I could get back on my feet. That won't help someone who's schizophrenic or drug-addicted.

Re:Social Darwinism at the Soup Kitchen by rfreytag on Thursday June 25, 2009 @10:01AM (#673636)
This raises the question - is addiction and mental issues a cause or an effect? How many came from homes where they learned poor social/societal skills. How many were forced to self-medicate (drugs) to staunch the pain?

There is a lot of evidence that stimulant abuse is a highly-correlated indicator of ADHD/ADD.

Scary that the breadline could be a lot closer than you think and but for some better pre-natal through pre-K care millions would be more productive members of society. We share in the cause when we do nothing useful to help.