Have you read the actual studies? There are no "mixed" studies, they're all conclusive. One of the biggest studies done was a decade long and found absolutely nothing.
Sources:
http://onlinelibrary.wiley.com/doi/10.1111/j.1365-2222.2009....
http://www.livestrong.com/article/408512-neurological-effect...
"Initially, researchers had success proving both the short-term and long-term dangers of MSG: mice injected with the additive showed signs of brain lesions, and humans fed 3 grams of MSG per 200 ml of soup presented symptoms congruent with “Chinese Restaurant Syndrome.” "
If you believe the original article is wrong, then you should perhaps make a comment in the main thread explaining why it is wrong instead of contradicting me. I merely assumed what the article said about the studies was more or less correct.
"Subsequent studies, however, provided mixed results: some confirmed findings of brain lesions in animals or symptoms in humans, but other studies were unable to replicate the results. Double-blind studies often showed little correlation between MSG and adverse symptoms. Parties on both sides of the debate slung accusations at the other, with the anti-MSG researchers claiming that studies were being funded by MSG producers, and pro-MSG researchers accusing the other side of fear-mongering.
From the FDA to the United Nations to various governments (Australia, Britain and Japan) the public bodies that have investigated MSG have deemed it a safe food additive. The FDA states on their website:
FDA considers the addition of MSG to foods to be “generally recognized as safe” (GRAS). Although many people identify themselves as sensitive to MSG, in studies with such individuals given MSG or a placebo, scientists have not been able to consistently trigger reactions.
Scientific interest in its deleterious effects seems to be waning: one of the last studies to gain public attention was published in 2011. The authors of that study claimed to have found a link between MSG and obesity, though those results have been questioned. While the general scientific consensus seems to be that only in large doses and on an empty stomach can MSG temporarily affect a small subset of the population, MSG’s reputation is still maligned in the public eye."
That last sentence is important.
So all my comments have been logically consistent with each other and my actual honest opinion. Thus they are quite undeserving of your half thought out response.
Good information generally cancels out bad information. I have no particular opinion about the veracity of any MSG claim, but there have been so many bad dietary studies published. I would urge a skeptical default position on any result, and only moderate skepticism based on evidence of sample size, methodology and rigor.
Your last sentence is very troubling: You feel the negative effects when eating certain foods that you 'suspect' contain MSG. To me, that really sounds like you may psyche yourself out. ie. that you worry about MSG so much that it starts to cause you stress about it, and it's a self-fulfilling prophecy/placebo effect/whatever. Anyway, I can't tell you with 100% certainty that MSG is healthy or not, but I can tell you that there are cultures that consume it in large quantities that seem largely unaffected.
It's true that we have a very limited understanding of the human body.
But this is the whole point. Unless there's some science to back something (or you have some personal experiences) then it's irrational to change your behaviour. [Note that I'm certainly not discounting personal experience here. Because the body is complicated, I think that's worth more than science. But you've got to be careful about your biases.]
The example of trans fats is an interesting one. AFAIK, the science (early 90s?) predated anyone seriously changing behaviour or policy. Although people suggested a connection earlier, it would not have been reasonable to start altering the entire food industry around some unsubstantiated claims. There are random connections suggested all the time. Unfortunately, they are only insightful in retrospect and no one remembers the ones that didn't turn out to be true.
> So I am very very suspicious of any food additives. The only rational decision for a human being is to eat the type of foods humans have eaten for tens of thousands of years before and for which our bodies have evolved.
While it's sane to be suspicious of food additives, I don't think it's rational to go back ten of thousands of years. Modern humans live much longer and are healthier than humans ten thousand years ago. There are plenty of modern additives about which there is little to no debate: * Iodine added to salt. * Vitamins A and D added to milk in Northern countries (incl. USA and Canada). * Fluoride added to tap water. I'm sure there are many other additives that are generally accepted as good, but I'm not aware of. And aside from additives, I certainly wouldn't want my food to stop being pasteurized...
> MSG is especially worrying because there are some studies that show negative effects of MSG and the fact that other studies show no effects does not quite negate these.
IIRC, the studies that showed negative effects were done by injecting MSG directly into rats. I believe the consensus is that the ingestion of glutamate is much different than direct injection. You consume glutamate every day in your food (I'm sure there are plenty of things you eat which would do very bad things if injected directly into your blood). I don't think anyone has the view that studies are negated because they are contradicted by others, but they are frequently negated due to poor protocols or new information.
I actually don't find MSG very worrying because it seems to be a cultural phenomenon, more than a scientific one. (There are many: third-hand smoking, resveratrol, anti-oxidants, etc. Not to say there's no science there, just that the cultural view is only tangentially related to the science. It's like our fan death.)
I went through my own little discovery: A few years ago, I was shocked to discover that a girl I was dating frequently cooked with an MSG sauce (she was from Mexico). Stunned, I researched the whole MSG thing. Turns out it's quite popular all over the world, except in english-speaking countries. The popular demonization stemmed from a few poorly-done studies that very quickly become part of the zeitgeist (it's suggested that this was partly due to racism/xenophobia since it was seen as an asian thing). And despite its widespread use for decades, there's no real evidence that suggests what people fear about it. And because of the fear, it's actually one of the most-tested of all food ingredients and yet it remains legal to sell and use as an additive everywhere.
> Furthermore, I myself feel negative effects when eating certain foods that I suspect of containing MSG.
One last quick point -- I don't think you should treat your own experience as the addendum. As you suggested, the human body is a complex system so I think the best thing that you can do is listen to your instincts. [Of course, you should also try to keep in mind the psychology at play. You feel bad, so you suspect the food has MSG; or you suspect the food has MSG, so you feel bad.]
An interesting personal anecdote about this: I used to eat that instant Ramen stuff all the time when I was in my 20s. At some point I started getting migraines and I was able to correlate the triggering of them with eating the Ramen (lots of other things triggered them, too). That led me to investigate MSG and become a little paranoid about eating things with it—I figured I might actually have some sensitivity to it.
Later I got diagnosed with hypertension and started taking pills to control that. And once I was on the medication I noticed that I wasn't getting migraines any more. At this point I'm reasonably sure that all my migraines were caused by high blood pressure. In fact, the one or two times I've gotten migraine-ish headaches (nothing ever as bad as I used to get) I've taken my blood pressure and it was high.
So now I'm thinking that the MSG wasn't causing the headaches directly, but it was raising my blood pressure. Or maybe it wasn't actually the MSG doing that, since that Ramen stuff also has a ton of salt in it.
Anyway, our bodies are complicated machines and they're all tuned a little different.
This is sort of true, but also not at all. Natural selection deals with incremental changes over the course of decades, or generations. The likelihood that, for instance, Omega 3 production will spontaneously arise in a tomato, is so small as to be negligible. GM represents a step-change in capability, closer to the possibilities of the use of industrial food additives, than it is to traditional breeding. Except, as I say, the additives are now an integral part of the ingredients.
Saying that the experimental results are mixed does not make me feel better. Experimenting with humans is very difficult, and certain types of experiments are downright impossible. Thus, effects of foods that do are not immediate and drastic are very hard to determine in human experiments.
Think about a food that we now know is very dangerous: trans fats. Humans had been eating trans fats for about 80 years when they were definitely found to cause heart attacks. Only then there was enough data to make a definite connection. And while there were some scientific articles that suggested a connection in the 60's someone could always say "there is no definite proof." Many people died of heart attacks before the statistics became such that a connection was obvious.
Then there is the tendency of people to wrongly assume that compounds that are kind of similar will have the identical effect on the body. Thus, for a long time carbohydrates were all bunched together because they were very similar molecules. People would often say that carbohydrates cannot be bad for you because humans have been eating rice and wheat for centuries without negative effects. But it turned out that fructose is a little different than other carbohydrates and it can be bad for you.
And then there is the fact that the same thing can be benign or very dangerous depending on what form it is in. Thus, fructose is absolutely benign when eaten as part of a fruit or vegetable, but quite harmful when eaten in a refined sugar or high fructose corn syrup form.
So I am very very suspicious of any food additives. The only rational decision for a human being is to eat the type of foods humans have eaten for tens of thousands of years before and for which our bodies have evolved. Maybe MSG is benign. Or maybe it is actually bad for you. I would prefer not to become one of those statistics that allows scientists to prove many years from now that MSG is indeed bad for you.
MSG is especially worrying because there are some studies that show negative effects of MSG and the fact that other studies show no effects does not quite negate these. Furthermore, I myself feel negative effects when eating certain foods that I suspect of containing MSG.