Can Facebook maybe deny me a business license? Cancel my passport? Is there a Facebook commando that would break down my doors if I did something Mark Zuckerberg didn't like? No?
Can we then stop pretending like corporations and governments play even remotely in the same league?
What can Google actually do? Target me with ads? I won't so much as see them.
And I don't use facebook, it barely raises an eyebrow. I couldn't try that with a national ID because I wouldn't be able to do anything.
Give everything to the NSA, IRS or anyone else that asks.
Edit: this one https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6680763
A few months ago they were using the "metadata" argument. Where are the prosecutions now that thats obviously BS?!
The reverse is not true, so if only the government is surveilling you, you can still stay out of some of the corporate databases.
Google, Facebook, et. al. can willfully share your information with the US or any other government.
AT&T gets paid $10 million annually for access to your data, and as a publicly traded company, if they don't do that, they're not being fair to their shareholders, to whom they've promised to maximize profits.
http://articles.washingtonpost.com/2013-07-21/world/40713603...
Yep, it's absurd to the extreme to compare the NSA and Feds to Google.
I also agree that you could make a convincing case that aside from the legality and broad social unacceptability of the collection, the way data is currently used by the government is much much more in line with the surveilled's interests than many of the businesses gobbling up consumer data. Corporate surveillance isn't inherently any better than government surveillance. Pretending otherwise makes us enablers.
So no, leaving Facebook or Google solves only a tiny part of the problem.
They did it with boeing and airbus http://www.economist.com/node/1842124 and who knows how many other companies.
And who knows what boeing did in return to gain the favor of NSA...
I don't see a very good future of fighting the 'surveillance internet' if we don't face the notion that once data is out there -- of lots of people, in one place -- NSA will always be interested in it and will probably get it. Pragmatically speaking, pulling out of Facebook, Google, etc. is the only surefire way to fight the surveillance internet.