News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by richforrester on Thursday November 07, 2013 @11:53PM (#6694524)
After reading this, watch Robocop again. Same director, same critique on society.

Really adds another layer to it.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by psbp on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:14AM (#6694583)
Robocop is even more over the top. One of the first scenes in Robocop is a guy being eviscerated with bullets in a board room meeting and one of the businessmen says "That's life in the big city!".

It's just dripping with satire.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by jholman on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:40AM (#6694648)
Starship Troopers has the heroes wearing Nazi uniforms, and it has a scene from in-fiction television, "teaching" children that killing terrestrial insects is what they should do to assist with the war on the bugs.

I don't remember much of Robocop, but how much more satirical can you get than that?

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by defen on Friday November 08, 2013 @01:08AM (#6694727)
Here is an in-movie ad for a product that exists in the Robocop universe: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=OmSSVt7Mfkk
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by jlgreco on Friday November 08, 2013 @03:06AM (#6695075)
In-movie propoganda reel from Starship Troopers: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=faFuaYA-daw Note Neil Patrick Harris sharply dressed in a rather SS-officer-esque uniform.

I'd say it's a tossup.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by PhasmaFelis on Friday November 08, 2013 @03:29AM (#6695154)
That's not much of a satire, given that the Nuclear War card game has been around since 1965. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nuclear_War_(card_game)
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by PhasmaFelis on Saturday November 09, 2013 @01:48AM (#6700931)
Could one of you folks downvoting me please tell me what you disagree with? I'm really not getting why this was controversial or offensive. Did you think I was badmouthing Robocop, or what?
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by DanBC on Friday November 08, 2013 @03:42AM (#6695200)
That scene originally lasted much longer. The robot spends ages shooting the guy. So long that it becomes ridiculous, comical.

Censors didn't like that scene, and they insisted it was cut down, with a shorter amount of time for shooting.

The effect is to turn something almost funny into something chilling and horrific.

Having the ED 209 be unable to tackle stairs is another example of the robot failing.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by enraged_camel on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:11AM (#6694576)
My memories are hazy, but Robocop felt very different. It did not criticize the establishment (i.e. the police) very much. In fact, the main character was a cop who got fatally wounded by "the bad guys" and then was resurrected as a badass robot and delivered sweet payback.

Most of the satirical elements in Robocop were directed at corporations.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by jontas on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:24AM (#6694607)
Watch it again.. the bad guys are not some random street thugs, it is OCP, a mega corporation that produces the robots and is essentially a government organization (since that world is a "corporatocracy").
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by potatolicious on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:33AM (#6694627)
More specifically, "the bad guys" and OCP were actually in cahoots. The CEO of OCP has the main villain kill a junior OCP executive after the executive humiliates the CEO.

There is also a subplot where OCP is deliberately working with street gangs to drive up the crime rate and gather public support for demolishing the entirety of old Detroit and building the corporate-owned "Delta City" in its place.

The movie does criticize the establishment, it just stops short of criticizing the actual street cops.

Side note: I'm actually looking forward to the remake. I had strong fears that the reboot would be strictly all-action and contain none of the social commentary. While it looks like the movies will lose its satirical elements, the cynicism will remain. I watched another movie by Jose Padilha recently and I'm hopeful.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by enraged_camel on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:52AM (#6694676)
>>The movie does criticize the establishment, it just stops short of criticizing the actual street cops.

That is what I meant. Contrast that to Starship Troopers, where the military (the organization the main characters are a part of) is spared no criticism.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by fricken4 on Friday November 08, 2013 @01:31AM (#6694783)
The central characters in Robocop were treated empathetically, the scathing social satire and black comedy were not central to the main storyline of heroes and villians, so there was still an engaging film even for those viewers lacking the social awareness needed to appreciate irony.

In Starship Troopers, every character was disposable, hence the gigantic 'whoosh'.

I recommend 'Hollow Man', Verhoeven's last, and largely forgotten Hollywood film, released in 2000. It's even more subversive, and the subversive message is even more subtle. So subtle in fact that I doubt even the film's producers were aware of what was going on. It's either a terrible B-grade hollywood sci-fi thriller, or brilliant black comedy, depending on whether or not you latch on to the subtext.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by Amadou on Friday November 08, 2013 @02:35AM (#6694999)
Another movie in the same vein is "Battleship." It "woooshed" a lot of people, but there are some controvertible clues that it was more than just an "America, fuck yeah!" movie. Most notably the song during the end credits which is Creedence's "Fortunate Son." I'm sure some people won't even be convinced by that fact, but then Reagan used Springsteen's "Born in the USA" during his campaign in 1984, so I guess some people just aren't wired for satire.

For me, the best thing about "Battleship" is how the director convinced the US military to donate the use of all that hardware to a movie with such an anti-military message. The DoD doesn't do that sort of thing lightly, they require script approval and have a strict policy that they won't help with a movie that is at all critical. Slipping that right under their noses like that was a real coup.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by ekianjo on Friday November 08, 2013 @01:13AM (#6694739)
I agree with your analysis of Robocop, but I'm not looking forward to the remake at all. There's no need for a remake. There is nothing that feels old about Robocop. Watch it again and it still stands as a great movie altogether. The remake will just put more nonsensical special effects and you can bet there will tons of crappy acting in it.
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by rodgerd on Friday November 08, 2013 @01:23AM (#6694769)
Vice-President, not CEO, is working with the gangs.
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by camus2 on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:24AM (#6694608)
yes it did critize the police. In Robocop,police officers are just cannon fodder for fabricated street wars set by big business. In fact corps own the police,the media,the city,politics and gang bangers are hired as "consultants".
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by maxerickson on Friday November 08, 2013 @09:23AM (#6696119)
The police officers portrayed in the movie are not part of the establishment that exists in the movie.

Especially the several officers at the precinct. They are shown fighting the good fight, fighting for the people, in the face of the impossible conditions coming down from above.

Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by radley on Friday November 08, 2013 @12:56AM (#6694685)
Go watch the "you have 20 seconds to comply" part again.
Re:Starship Troopers: one of the most misunderstood movies ever by rodgerd on Friday November 08, 2013 @01:23AM (#6694768)
Sadly it ends up feeling more like a roadmap these days.