If running a postal service that reaches all of the country is a money losing proposition, that's a terrible reason to privatize it, if you think it's in the national benefit to have a postal service.
1. Hard-line libertarians who argue that, since a post office is neither a national defense nor a means of enforcing contracts, it is beyond the scope of government and thus doomed to fail so long as it is run by government, and
2. Private entities who compete with the post office on package delivery, and would like to see that competition reduced by demonstrating how much more "efficient" (i.e., profitable) they are than a government-run delivery service.
http://www.apwu.org/news/webart/2011/11-015-prcletter-paea_r...
I am pointing out that the unions hate the law because they see how terrible it is.
It is in the union's best interest to hide the cost of the pensions for as long as possible, with the likely result of taxpayers funding pensions.
Your analysis assumes the public implementation is equivalent with a private one.
The reality is that without the enforced monopoly of the USPS and the Congress to protect it, a private business would be profitable.
They'd also charge more to achieve it.
But that's Capitalism, and by all means mail is most likely artificially priced far below what the market would naturally support.
This wouldn't necessarily mean that they'd raise prices across the board, but for some residences, it would almost certainly require more than $0.42 (or whatever it is now) to deliver to.
My uncle owns over 2,000 mountainy acres in an extremely rural area. Mail to his house takes his postman literally a half an hour out of his way, through treacherous (but paved, sort of) roads, and which is impossible to deliver to in a snow storm. Still, it only takes the cost of a single stamp for me to send him a letter.
Him being a nice guy though, has an arrangement with the local post office (or maybe just the postman, I don't know how official or allowed it is) where they suspend junk mail until something legit comes in so that they don't have to make erroneous trips except for when he actually has a package. If he happens to be in town and hasn't received mail, he'll swing by the post office and pick his mail up there.
http://www.unitedstateszipcodes.org/
For all, background info on the USPS budget/deficit:
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/07/31/opinion/nocera-its-d-day-f...
http://www.gao.gov/products/GAO-13-872T
Imagine for a moment working for a company that had had been in business for 220+ years, had policy and procedure manuals that reflected every year of the history, had thousands of physical locations, delivered to millions of locations many times per week, and had 535 people on the board of directors (in the sense of trying to micro-manage whatever they felt like sticking their oar into.)
I find it somewhat amazing that the USPS can still deliver mail across the country for less than 50 cents, let alone all the other stuff they can handle - ever been shipped a hive of bees by mail? It's in the Domestic Mail Manual, under Bees http://pe.usps.com/text/dmm300/601.htm