News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Silicon Valley tech foundation launches $1 million compet... by hga on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @03:11PM (#6685139)
This is the usual "smart gun" bullshit, which wouldn't make an appreciable positive difference in the situation.

For one thing, it's telling they start out with a lie. Safety, if used honestly in this context, refers to preventing accidents, which are an "official" 600 deaths per year problem (scare quotes because I know criminal homicides that are scored as "accidents" for the usual political reasons; details on request).

The real issue is intentional homicides, i.e. guns being as designed. Note we're talking about a nation with > 300 million existing old fashioned guns in civilian hands, where in the last ~40 month every month except for last August has seen greater sales than the previous month a year ago, currently running at a million a month. Note that with a very minimum of care guns are functional for decades and decades: I would not feel inadequately armed with a Mauser 1898 (sic) rifle made in that year or soon after, and my teen centerfire hunting rifle was sporterized surplus Springfield 03A3, designed in 1903 (using a few Mauser patents :-) and manufactured during WWII. The 3rd most recent gun I bought was a M1 "Get Off My Lawn" Garand made a few months after Pearl Harbor (and boy does a part of me wish I hadn't sold that masterpiece of then cutting edge technology to buy a lighter rifle more suitable for my RSI injured arms).

The conceit that somehow these new, expensive and less reliable smart guns will displace the barest fraction of the above existing ones is ludicrous. Even if you take a long view, it would take centuries.

Then there's the laws, like fanatically anti-gun New Jersey's one that once there's a "smart gun" on the market, civilians will only be able to buy it. But, somehow, the Only Ones AKA the law enforcement officers who our betters insist are the only ones who can be trusted with guns (https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=6680266) will be allowed to retain their old "unsafe" guns. Perhaps because everyone knows they'll be a lot more reliable.

In a county where almost every state has a shall issue concealed carry regime (obviously excluding most of California for now---the object lesson of Illinois should give you pause if you're happy with that state of affairs), adoption of these inherently more complicated and therefore less reliable guns would surely result more of the wrong people being shot. Although one could assume from how this is portrayed that to the extent the backers of this are engaging in rational thought they score all "gun deaths" as the same.

Let me make this as a bottom line closer: if you think there's fierce opposition to Obamacare, just try to push these on an unwilling population....

There are no comments on this comment yet.