Re:Apple hides a Patriot-Act-busting "warrant canary" in its...
by Spooky23 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @08:58AM
(#6682661)
I agree that it's useless, with the exception of smaller organizations where the key players are involved with everything. In those, the risk of someone going "all Lavabit" and doing something dramatic are a deterrent.
All the government needs to do is give a gag order to the people processing the warrant. The folks putting the transparency report together will truthfully report that no such warrant exists, because they are unaware of it.
This isn't a big spy thing either -- if you've ever worked in a place where one or more executives or a business unit were subject to an investigation of some sort, this happens. The gag orders are there to avoid intentional or accidental disclosure to the custodian of the data in question, which could lead to tampering with or destruction of evidence. Its an uncomfortable situation that many email administrators have found themselves in for many years.
The scary thing about the Section 215 warrants from my perspective as an individual is the difficulty in disclosing things to counsel to get appropriate advice, broad scope and indefinite nature of the gag order. It was one thing when these laws were used to investigate KGB agents -- now you have orders of magnitude more of these things.
All the government needs to do is give a gag order to the people processing the warrant. The folks putting the transparency report together will truthfully report that no such warrant exists, because they are unaware of it.
This isn't a big spy thing either -- if you've ever worked in a place where one or more executives or a business unit were subject to an investigation of some sort, this happens. The gag orders are there to avoid intentional or accidental disclosure to the custodian of the data in question, which could lead to tampering with or destruction of evidence. Its an uncomfortable situation that many email administrators have found themselves in for many years.
The scary thing about the Section 215 warrants from my perspective as an individual is the difficulty in disclosing things to counsel to get appropriate advice, broad scope and indefinite nature of the gag order. It was one thing when these laws were used to investigate KGB agents -- now you have orders of magnitude more of these things.