Re:After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal...
by Intermernet on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @03:29AM
(#6681577)
As someone with personal experience with this, I can say that "revenge" is the wrong reason for punishment. Punishment handed out by society should be about dissuading other members of that society from behaving against the society's best interests. Anything else is personal.
As soon as "revenge" comes into it, the self-perpetuating downward spiral of justifying bad behavior as punishment for bad behavior begins.
Individuals in society who gain pleasure from the punishment of others, whether that punishment was deserved or not, should realize they're really just being sadistic.
Re:After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal...
by Jayschwa on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @01:01AM
(#6681025)
I believe revenge on an individual level can be morally legit.
Re:After traffic stop, man forced to have x-ray, enema, anal...
by mburns on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @01:17AM
(#6681080)
Well that's fine, but we're not comparing personal opinions. This tangent was brought to us by smokeyj's ramblings about the injustice of governments doing bad things with unequal punishment, and edias explaining why he's full of it.
Reality is well established that government plays a different role than individuals and is explicitly given permissions we refuse to citizens by way of the Constitution.
People can't own ICBMs or atomic bombs, either, which is their sovereign right if not for the oppressive government.
An individual does not have right to punish another person in response to a crime after the fact (A.K.A. revenge). Collectively, we do.