News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by oftenwrong on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:10PM (#6678333)
You love open source software, but not enough to use an open source OS
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by redblacktree on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:15PM (#6678370)
That actually describes me. I hate dicking around with drivers and the like (though I've heard Ubuntu got better), so I like the unixy OSX quite a lot.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by mgkimsal on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:28PM (#6678458)
"though I've heard Ubuntu got better"

I've heard that about linux every year for the past 14 years, usually from people who've only been using desktop linux for a year or two. Not exclusively, but usually.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by the_hangman on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:51PM (#6678648)
Ubuntu is alright -- the problem with Linux as an OS 'for the people' is that the people find the command line frightening.

Putting a pretty UX on top of Linux and making it easier to use just moves users further and further away from 'Linux' and closer and closer to an OS X or Windows, only without the games, hardware compatibility, and enterprise software options.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by markdown on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:58PM (#6679103)
> closer and closer to an OS X or Windows

Which is the best way for an average user to interact with the machine, is it not?

The ideal OS would be OS X levels of usable, but built entirely on Free Software. Once such an OS exists, it will draw in users, and the games/hardware-compatibility etc will always follow the users.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by andyroid on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:28PM (#6678907)
And you somehow doubt that to be true, or what is your point?
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by mgkimsal on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:57PM (#6679098)
"better" is always subjective, and it's never even been close to my expectations.

I don't think most people who've told me "oh, <foo> has gotten a lot better in the last year" even know what the problems are that keep some people away. I think it's largely PR parroting, and a way to seem marginally 'with it' re: linux. "hey yeah, I know ubuntu had some issues in the past, but you should really try it now - it's a lot better!" - just got 2 emails from people in the last week or so asking why I use OSX.

I was a desktop/laptop linux user from 2000-2008. That's about 9 years of "oh hey - things are so much better this year". And yet... in 2008 I still had issues trying to have multiple apps access audio at the same time. I still had issues plugging in an external monitor on a laptop (or 2 monitors on a desktop). I grew tired of rickety perlgtk scripts that were marginal wrappers around Xorg config files that never quite ever worked the way I could interpret the man page info. I've used desktop ubuntu distros virtualbox and vmware over the past couple years - things don't seem to have gotten that much better, mostly because the majority of the developers in those ecosystems don't see these things as massive problems to be solved in the first place (indeed, with some, it's a badge of honor that things are still hard to configure).

Again, the point is "hey, linux is better on the desktop now", in my experience, comes from people who've never really used it for a long time and had moderate expectations not met. Many people I know that use desktop linux expect it to be subpar for many things, and when it's just 'par' they herald this as a big improvement.

That said, I really miss fish from KDE.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by brdrak on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @07:27PM (#6679637)
Linux user for 15 years, Debian/Ubuntu exclusively for the past 7 or so. IMO, it's without question that the Desktop experience is better every year, now to a point where it just works 99.9% of the time (in my experience, anyway). Haven't had a any problems with sound or multiple monitors in a while (using both Nvidia and ATI video cards).

Of course people will and should use whatever they want. I have to touch Windows and Macs regularly as well and they're not without problems. Each will have its pros/cons like anything else.

Sounds like you're annoyed with people asking you why you use OSX. I've asked that question myself in the past. I assume people make informed choices, so I'm always curious about the reasons. Personally, I don't mind people asking me why I use Linux.

I will say that the Desktop experience still is the weak point compared with how solid everything else is. Xorg is a pain, but I haven't had to touch it in a few years (defaults have been working fine for me), so that's been fine.

The reason I keep using Linux is not because it's perfect, but because the breadth of amazing and ridiculously easily accessible free software available for the Debian ecosystem is unparalleled (in my experience, anyway).

I can run the same software on servers, desktops, laptops, in the cloud, on crappy old hardware in a way not possible with Windows or Mac. I don't have to ask for permission or deal with licensing issues. I can focus on GSD* instead.

* getting shit done -- see other thread :-)

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by mgkimsal on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:59PM (#6680303)
Not annoyed by the question, more bemused. Every few months as I meet new people, I routinely get a linux fan telling me how awesome everything is on desktop linux. It's the same enthusiastic fanboyism that drew me in in 99/2000. When ubuntu came out, the "everything just works" mantra was pushed heavily in the circles I was in, but... everything didn't work. The fact that you had a nice installer - great. My wireless cards still didn't work well. Sound drivers were a problem. Etc. I've posted most of it before.

Sort of like movies I guess - people pushing their favorite actors who were in some remake of something from 20 years ago. The actors are OK, but I'm not becoming a crazed fan over that stuff; life's too short.

As for linux - it's on all the servers I manage, and I can run virtual machines of what I need from linux, mac or windows when required. It's just not my cup of tea for desktop/laptops, and probably won't be for a long time (again). The macbook "just works" far in excess of any hype from the ubuntu crowd (again, thinking back to 8-10 years ago - "it just works!")

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by marincounty on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @12:06AM (#6680820)
"just works!" but not for Mavericks. I wish I didn't download it. I now need to hand over more money to Microsoft. Something I never thought I would do. Office 2004 doesn't work.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by Moto7451 on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @12:19AM (#6680857)
Office 2004 is a PPC app and stopped working in Mac OS 10.7
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by lucasnemeth on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @11:02AM (#6683331)
Agree. Desktop Linux do have it problems, it is getting better every year, but it's linux weakest point. I can lose some time eventually with mundane things. But the ease I have on deploying things, testing things, etc. the things that matter for my work, it's incomparable.

On a side note: I have some sound problems every once in a while, but I am a hard user of audio libraries, since I perform in music concerts using live coding... In the normal everyday department, it just works.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by jebblue on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:58PM (#6679470)
Linux desktop, CentOS, SuSE, Fedora, Ubuntu all have worked fine for me the past 15 years. I have fewer problems than when I have to do something on/with Windows. So either all my machines and all my experiences were really lucky or your post is an elegant troll.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by mgkimsal on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @10:35PM (#6680458)
nothing trolling about it.

https://bbs.archlinux.org/viewtopic.php?id=120003

2011 people having problems with multiple apps trying to use audio at the same time. This is one of the things that drove me away from desktop linux in 2008. 3 years later it still isn't a solved problem. My gut tells me that in 2013, it's still not a solved problem.

I've no doubt that some people get it to work for their use cases OK. But the fact that it was, even 2 years ago, enough of a problem that people still encountered it... architecturally, that's a symptom of something really broken.

I'm not really interested in learning the ins and outs of modprobe and kernel driver recompiles to try to get sound working as I expect it to - it works the way I expect it to on my macbook, which leaves me time to do other more important stuff.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by phaemon on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @02:41AM (#6681393)
> it works the way I expect it to on my macbook

What? Not at all? Not working when you unplug headphones? Not working for Flash?

Google for "osx sound problem" and you'll get plenty hits. What exactly do you think your link from 2011 demonstrates?

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by mgkimsal on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @08:51AM (#6682622)
My anecdotal evidence using my MacBooks (3 since 2008) carry as much weight as anyone else's linux anecdotes.

And osx is by no means perfect. I just have had far fewer problems related to hardware and drivers than I ever did on Linux.

In 9 years of desktop linux, audio was a constant problem. It's been an extremely rare issue on my MacBooks.

What it demonstrates is that even in 2011, the base issues of how audio should even work hadn't really been sorted out. oss vs alas vs pulseaudio vs whatever aren't issues I want to be concerning myself with - this is just one reason I left for the macbook world.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by phaemon on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @05:31PM (#6685978)
...and I've had no problems with Linux sound since I tried to force JACK to do things no sane human should. Your anecdotes illustrate nothing.

I was using macbooks at the same time for our video editing. Don't pretend they don't spin that beachball crap at you at the worst moments.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by unmei on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @08:23AM (#6682524)
Also, they are using ALSA instead of PulseAudio. In my experience, the latter deals with multiple sources much better, to the point that I can even route and combine sources for streaming.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by redblacktree on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @07:48PM (#6679726)
We weren't comparing Linux and Windows. I also agree that Linux wins hands-down in that particular matchup (unless you want to game...). The question for me is OSX vs Linux, and for me, OSX is WAY easier, and I get most of the deliciousness of Linux on the command line.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by brdrak on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @08:25PM (#6679899)
A lot of people do prefer OSX. Between OSX and Windows, I'd choose OSX in a heartbeat because cygwin wasn't so great when I tried it a while back.

I did try OSX for a while, and wanted to like it because I can get it for free at work, but I'm so used to Linux that OSX quirks really annoyed me. Things like package management being an aftermarket hack, pain trying to get functional RAID10, Apple changing core functionality between releases breaking my setup, etc. For me, Linux is WAY easier. :-)

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by redblacktree on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @07:10AM (#6682275)
> For me, Linux is WAY easier. :-)

A fair point. Thanks for posting. I never really got good at running Linux on the desktop; I gave up each time I tried, due to a sound driver issue or similar. I suppose if I'd stuck with it, I might feel as you do.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by kayoone on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @02:15AM (#6681296)
funny thing is that OSX works pretty flawless on my Core2Quad hackintosh (zero issues with standby, audio, wifi, bluetooth) while Ubuntu 13.x on the same machine gave me some headaches and random behavior like standby not working properly from time to time etc.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by cseelus on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @07:30PM (#6679660)
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by mgkimsal on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @08:53AM (#6682635)
not the same as the fish protocol I remember from kde, but looks interesting. thanks!
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by kevincrane on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:45PM (#6678598)
FWIW, Ubuntu works out of the box on my laptop (a 13" Dell Vostro). No tweaking drivers, no BIOS stuff, just installing it as you would with Windows.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by lotyrin on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @10:25PM (#6680423)
Isn't this true of a huge number of people, given the state of Desktop Linux?

Additionally, many people can't afford to give up having commercial support for their OS as a target for software products (Adobe's in particular, in my experience).

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by lazerwalker on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:46PM (#6678606)
The tone of the job posting might be laughable, but those aren't in opposition to each other unless you're demanding Stallman levels of fanaticism.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by davidw on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:34PM (#6678946)
It hardly requires 'Stallman levels of fanaticism' to prefer an OS that you can explore and tinker with, if you're someone who likes to know - or maybe even tweak - how things work under the hood. A "hacker", in other words.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by lazerwalker on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @06:35PM (#6679320)
I tinker and play with Linux all the time, on servers and VMs. Saying that "you don't love open source enough to use an open source OS" implies to me that OSS is intrinsically better and preferable to non-OSS, even if a closed-source alternative would be better for your personal needs. That strikes me as fairly dogmatic (although it's very possible I misread the original intent).

I personally use OS X as my desktop OS because it suits my needs, despite contributing regularly to open source. I agree completely that there are many non-'fanatical' reasons to prefer Linux as a desktop OS.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by Widdershin on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:28PM (#6678463)
This is totally me. I spend tons of time bitching about Windows, but I never just up and move to *nix because of some Windows exclusive things I want.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by ancarda on Wednesday November 06, 2013 @06:06AM (#6682063)
That actually sums me up quite well. For various reasons, I just don't get along on Linux. It always made me run back to Windows, but I wanted to use open/free software. I eventually settled on OS X as it allowed me to use most of the programs I liked from Linux without having to sacrifice a good desktop environment.

To summarize; "I'll use free software but not if it means neglecting superior proprietary software".

Obviously to each his own in this matter. Linux is great in some areas but not for user experience or corporate support.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by benihana on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @04:44PM (#6678590)
I mean technically OS X is an open source OS with a closed-sourced windowing system built on top of it.

I hate myself for posting this comment.

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by zimbatm on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:22PM (#6678866)
_Your dark troll side has spoken_. I'm not even sure that that's technically correct, it's probably not possible to get the same kernel by compiling Darwin. I would be surprised if Apple kept pushing new feature into the open source kernel.
Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by pmjordan on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @10:37PM (#6680469)
They do keep adding stuff to the open source portion, but you're right that there's plenty of closed source code running on a stock OS X kernel. This is loaded in as kexts, so the mach_kernel binary itself is open and reproducible. Drivers for anything vaguely recent are all closed, as are any security related things (crypto, firewall, sandbox, quarantine, etc.) and a few other odds and ends. Recompiling the kernel is entirely doable [1] (and occasionally useful for kext development), though running a kernel with literally no proprietary code will be quite a lot of effort. (and various important bits of OSX userspace will cease functioning)

[1] I've personally had success with the instructions at http://shantonu.blogspot.com/ - not that Apple has accepted any of my patches...

Re:We Work Remotely – New Job Board from 37 Signals by ebarock on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @05:48PM (#6679037)
Nah! You don't need to hate your self, OS X is good and that's it! hehe