thx, I think I understand what you are saying,
my (perhaps snarky) comment was more to do with 'why be so careful' with the potential data failure (that circus handily addresses) when data is being placed in a 'leaky bucket' (redis) in the first place.
e.g. 1/ notify the world you don't accept data anymore 2/ process what you have enqueued 3/ shutdown. In Fabien's use case 1 -> 3 can last for over 5 minutes.