Re:How to Cut the Poverty Rate in Half
by pbhjpbhj on Tuesday November 05, 2013 @09:51AM
(#6675310)
>if you gave a person making 0 per year 30K per year they would suddenly have an apartment, healthcare, transportation, and all those other things that most other people who make 30K per year have //
It's a poor premise. There's a wearing down effect that poverty has. Over time one can rely quite a bit on past wealth - for example clothing starts wearing out after a year (shoes) but can last decades depending on wear. [estimated periods:] A house needs re-roofing in 20 years, a boiler needs replacing in 10 years, a car needs replacing when it's 15 years old, et cetera.
It's quite easy to live on a low income for a shorter period. In 6 months you're still using all the things you had when you were better off - probably you still have some foodstuffs. Coming the other direction in 6 months of higher income you'd still be spending on those things that have worn out.
The $15k for 6 months would make a dramatic change, IMO, but not necessarily one that a casual observer would notice. As an example, I would probably still be wearing worn out clothes but the house would be in a good state of repair, we'd have a fully working cooker and washing machine, etc..
>we shouldn't care how much money anybody makes, but whether they live a comfortable, happy life and have access to opportunity //
It's a poor premise. There's a wearing down effect that poverty has. Over time one can rely quite a bit on past wealth - for example clothing starts wearing out after a year (shoes) but can last decades depending on wear. [estimated periods:] A house needs re-roofing in 20 years, a boiler needs replacing in 10 years, a car needs replacing when it's 15 years old, et cetera.
It's quite easy to live on a low income for a shorter period. In 6 months you're still using all the things you had when you were better off - probably you still have some foodstuffs. Coming the other direction in 6 months of higher income you'd still be spending on those things that have worn out.
The $15k for 6 months would make a dramatic change, IMO, but not necessarily one that a casual observer would notice. As an example, I would probably still be wearing worn out clothes but the house would be in a good state of repair, we'd have a fully working cooker and washing machine, etc..
>we shouldn't care how much money anybody makes, but whether they live a comfortable, happy life and have access to opportunity //
Yes, amen.