News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:'Sweetie', a computer-generated girl, lures sex predators by anigbrowl on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:45PM (#6672645)
That's an unsettled question - a political one, in many ways. We certainly have some interest in deterring criminal acts, as Rayiner explains.

Also, intent and thought are not the exact same thing in legal terms. For example, I have certainly daydreamed about robbing a bank - not because I want to take anyone else's money particularly, but because it's amusing to imagine what sort of clever tricks you might employ to pull it off. I'm sure you've noticed there's a whole genre of movies and crime novels about likable criminals pulling off an elaborate heist, doesn't mean the film production people or the audience that enjoys the films actually want to take up a life of crime.

Now if I start making all the preparations to commit a robbery - enlisting co-conspirators, or acquiring weapons, or suborning employees of the bank, etc. I've obviously gone quite a way past simple daydreaming. Such acts are demonstrative of my intention. Picture yourself sitting in a car outside a bank, with a bag on your lap that contains a gun, a ransom note, and a mask. You'd obviously be in a very different frame of mind from someone who was simply musing on the general possibility of robbing a bank, and a prosecutor would certainly be justified in asking a jury to take that into account if you were on trial for attempt or conspiracy.

There are no comments on this comment yet.