News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Few successful entrepreneurs blog by philwelch on Monday November 04, 2013 @03:53PM (#6671090)
To me, a "blog" is a particular format of online writing, but not all online writing is blogging. You can tell because newspapers often have blogs separate from their other content, drawing a distinction. I think there's a similar distinction between "essays that happen to be posted online" and "blogs".
Re:Few successful entrepreneurs blog by Typhon on Monday November 04, 2013 @05:23PM (#6671619)
Interestingly, my own definition of blogging is not tied to a specific medium.

To me, the defining characteristics of the blog are as follows :

A collection of texts which are :

1 - Published incrementally as they are written, and chronologically organized.

2 - Meant to be read by a wide audience

3 - Usually not ran past an editor.

4 - Not necessarily sharing any common theme

5 - Usually all have the same author.

I cooked up this definition after noticing that the EWDs had been more or less Dijkstra's blog, long before the Web.

PG's essays obviously fall under this definition as well.

Re:Few successful entrepreneurs blog by philwelch on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:34PM (#6672252)
I don't think PG's blogs are chronologically organized in any meaningful fashion. I also think that your definition is too broad, as it would include any self-published book series or maybe even the Bible.
Re:Few successful entrepreneurs blog by Typhon on Monday November 04, 2013 @07:56PM (#6672366)
I originally included "short" as a criterion, but I removed it as subjective. And PG's essays are chronologically organized : the topmost are the most recent.
Re:Few successful entrepreneurs blog by philwelch on Monday November 04, 2013 @08:42PM (#6672626)
Again that's so vague as to be meaningless--you have to order them somehow and I don't think having a page that lists them in chronological order makes it a blog. At the very least most blogs show the full content of multiple posts on the same page, or have links to previous and next posts.

I think the defining feature of a blog that's absent from Graham's essays is that blog posts can be intentionally insubstantial, sometimes containing nothing more than a link, possibly with comments. The least substantial essay Paul Graham has written is probably the one where he clarifies that he's not a racist just because he thinks having a thick accent makes it hard to be a CEO. I don't think he would consider posting intentionally insubstantial content to his list of essays.