News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:John Boyd and the four qualities of victorious organizations by dragonwriter on Monday November 04, 2013 @12:59PM (#6670045)
> I've been a student of the concept of the OODA loop for about 6 or 7 years now. I've found that it shows up in different names all over every where.

OODA is essentially just another name for the scientific method, so its not really that surprising that it shows up under different names all over everywhere.

(Note: that I'm not intending to minimize the value of OODA by pointing out that it is just another name for the scientific method -- successfully explaining the scientific method in terms that get people to understand it and apply it effectively in specific domains -- particularly ones that have strong, established cultures that resist adaptation, is a significant accomplishment.)

> It's what Scrum is all about.

Well, its what Agile (and perhaps more to the point, Lean) is all about; Scrum is a tightly defined set of processes that comes with the caveat that if you aren't doing this exact set of processes as described, you aren't doing Scrum, and as such its somewhat in tension with OODA.

Re:John Boyd and the four qualities of victorious organizations by hosh on Monday November 04, 2013 @06:48PM (#6672030)
The scientific method is a method to create and verify plausible explanations for phenomena.

Strategic thinking is a method to make decisions in face of uncertainty. There is nothing scientific about it, though there are tactics in which a commander might make probing attacks to gain intelligence and test the adversary. Ultimately though, you are making decisions and taking action with inherently incomplete information.

One of the things that happen in adversarial dynamics is to use misinformation to screw around with someone else's OODA loop.

So no, OODA and strategic thinking in general are not essentially just another name for the scientific method, though it may employ science, or a skeptical stance as one of many tools to make decisions and take action. That frame of thinking exposes a limited understanding of OODA and strategy, one that is exploitable by an adversary.

Re:John Boyd and the four qualities of victorious organizations by shloky on Monday November 04, 2013 @01:29PM (#6670215)
Kind of disagree with the first part. But only from a perspective stand point. (Top of the structure vs half way up.)

Basically, I contend that OODA is probably the best model of human cognition - how humans capture and process information into behavior. All behavior.

The scientific method is just one application of OODA. One designed to answer questions.

Re:John Boyd and the four qualities of victorious organizations by dpritchett on Monday November 04, 2013 @01:54PM (#6670382)
Right, I don't think the scientific method captures the competitive timing aspects of the wider OODA framework.