News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by grandalf on Saturday June 20, 2009 @07:12PM (#666943)
Buyer beware. I used an M for a few years and it got me in the habit of pounding the keys, which has led to some pretty serious RSI.

Before the M I used to type far more delicately.

Keep in mind that the M was designed so that secretaries who were used to clunky mechanical typewriters could make the switch to computers. Nostalgia for the M is as misplaced as wanting a hand crank starter on the grill of your prius.

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by nileshk on Saturday June 20, 2009 @11:17PM (#667071)
I suggest reading "The Mindbody Prescription" by John E Sarno. Here is an overview of what it talks about: http://www.rsi.deas.harvard.edu/handout.doc (I know it's a Word doc, but that is the best overview I've seen)

It helped me recover 100% from what I thought was "RSI" and I no longer believe that typing can cause injury.

I bought a Unicomp Model M a few years after this recover, not for nostalgia, but to increase my typing speed and accuracy, which it did. The only downside is that it is loud.

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by holygoat on Sunday June 21, 2009 @02:48AM (#667195)
When I had my serious RSI episode, about 7 years ago, I observed that simply sitting at my desk or looking at my computer from across the room would induce pain in my mousing hand.

There was a majority physical component -- actually using the mouse was much, much more painful -- but there was also a psychological component. I suspect that this was anticipatory tension or somesuch, similar to a flinch response.

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by lutorm on Sunday June 21, 2009 @02:06AM (#667167)
I'm a longterm RSI sufferer, now largely recovered, and I while I agree that there is certainly something to the theory that stress and reduced blood flow is part of the problem, it seems to me that he's overstating his case:

"To be perfectly clear: in TMS theory, the cause of pain is not the structural abnormalities (tendon or muscle tears, tissue inflammation, herniation, degeneration, decrepit muscles, etc) or behavioral “problems” (poor posture, a bad ergonomic setup, improper typing habits) typically identified by medical practitioners. None of them are responsible for the pain – none."

My personal experience readily invalidates this. I can type for a full day on my Kinesis Advantage practically without a problem these days, but if I sit with the Macbook for a day, I can certainly feel the strain. Doing that for 2-3 days will bring back quite a lot of discomfort. Why would I all of a sudden have more unconscious stress just because I moved from working at my desk to the couch?

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by nileshk on Sunday June 21, 2009 @09:46AM (#667380)
That experience doesn't invalidate what he says, in fact its right in line with it. I suggest reading his book to fully understand it. Here is my take on it (which probably doesn't explain things as well as the book does):

Your belief is that the Kinesis keyboard causes you no discomfort, but the Macbook keyboard does. You've conditioned yourself to react this way; and your subconcious mind is fully aware of what is going on and is orchestrating the reactions and exploiting your beliefs so that it can cause distractions. The distractions are to prevent repressed emotions from surfacing. The actual physical reaction is real (oxygen deprivation to the areas), it's not "all in your head", but the root cause is psychological. The mind is in control here.

There may be some physical component to it. It may actually be more strenuous to use the MacBook keyboard than the Kinesis keyboard. Or in my case, slamming my fingers down aggressively on an arcade-style game controller for an hour probably could cause some discomfort. But that doesn't mean it will lead to a long-standing injury or chronic pain. Your subconcious mind will use the knowledge of what you think causes discomfort.

Of course you should see a doctor to rule out things like multiple sclerosis. I had been to many different doctors and tried various alternative therapies as well (such as acupuncture), and tried different ergonomic changes (including the Kinesis contoured keyboard), all which did not help me. So I was in a position where I was open to trying anything that could help me, and this was the only thing that did.

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by lutorm on Sunday June 21, 2009 @10:46AM (#667408)
I see what you're aiming at, but I'm skeptical. I'm happy it worked for you, though. The thing that helped me was http://www.triggerpointbook.com/
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by grandalf on Sunday June 21, 2009 @06:06PM (#667858)
This is totally fascinating. Would you care to share more about your experience and how you cured yourself?
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by nileshk on Friday June 26, 2009 @08:41AM (#675338)
I have been meaning to finish writing some blog entries that detail the whole thing. If you're interested here they are in their not-ready-to-be-published form:

Short version: http://www.nileshk.com/node/73 Long version: http://www.nileshk.com/node/71

I've been meaning to finish editing these entries for a while, so I will try to do that sometime soon. If you'd like me to notify you when I've finished them, you can e-mail me at hackernews /AT/ nileshk.com.

The "long version" doesn't talk much about how I actually cured myself yet, but really details everything that lead up to it. But really, there wasn't much to the actually cure. I read the outline that I linked to, and it just made sense to me. I immediately read The Mindbody Prescription and it was like it explained everything that I had been experiencing and why it happened the way it did. After I finished reading it, I immediately just started trying to go back to normal and doing the things I do without restrictions. I started repeatedly telling myself "there's nothing physically wrong with me." After a week my pain was almost gone, and I told my employers that I'm ready to start working full time again (I was working part-time at that time). A month later I was completely back to normal, typing without pain and without fear of the pain returning, playing my musical instruments without pain, and using my hands and arms without any restrictions.

I did also take a look at the things in my life that could have caused repressed emotions. Things that had emotionally effected me, but I just wasn't dealing with. I tried to force myself to face these things by just thinking about them and trying to "feel" the emotions that they caused. This was a gradual process over the course of the next months, and is an ongoing thing I continue to do.

Now the reason this worked for me was because I immediately completely believed the ideas it presented. In my case things were lining up for me to come to this realization, I just needed it explained to me the right way (in a scientific, concrete sort of way that I can make sense of and believe). So there is this "leap of faith" you have to take with this approach, which makes it difficult for a lot of people. For me it was easy to take, because it made sense of everything I had experienced (even some things before the wrist pain), whereas before I was confused as to why such a thing could happen and only had useless diagnoses such as "fibromyalgia" or "thoracic outlet syndrome" from my doctors. For me, there had been lots of hints as to what was really going on, but no clear explanation until I came across this.

What I'd suggest (assuming you've already seen a neurologist and eliminated diseases like MS as possibilities) is read this book, and if it doesn't immediately make sense to you, just keep it in mind and start observing the patterns of how your pain occurs. Give it another read after a while and see if it makes sense.

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by 10ren on Sunday June 21, 2009 @04:31AM (#667245)
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by grandalf on Sunday June 21, 2009 @02:39PM (#667633)
I'll check that out.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by jacobolus on Sunday June 21, 2009 @01:57AM (#667163)
I find that a Model M allows much softer typing than other keyboards, and much more predictable. If you're pounding the keys you're doing it wrong.

(This is precisely the point of having a resistance curve that is very easy through the part of the keypress where the actual contact is made, and then increases smoothly so that pushing the key all the way down is neither necessary nor desirable. It lets you not jam the keys down, and even gives you aural and tactile feedback to let you know when you’ve pressed the key far enough.)

(Edit: here's some images for the happy hacking keyboard; I'm sure I've seen this in English, but I'm not sure where. http://www.pfu.fujitsu.com/hhkeyboard/leaflet/keyspec.html )

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by jodrellblank on Sunday June 21, 2009 @10:19AM (#667393)
This is one thing I like about the design of the DataHand - there is no electrical contact to close. The keys have a magnet holding them onto the base, and when you press them you break the magnetic grip and push the key through an optical sensor.

There's no need to slam the keys until you hit a stop just to make sure they make contact. There's also not much chance you can push the key 'a bit' and have it not register, i.e. if you press it hard enough to move the key then they key moves past the sensor, otherwise it doesn't move at all.

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by jseliger on Saturday June 20, 2009 @07:46PM (#666966)
Maybe—but I've been using a Model M or Tactile Pro for years and haven't had this problem.

How do you know the particular style of keyboard led to the RSI and not some other factor?

Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by grandalf on Saturday June 20, 2009 @09:18PM (#667014)
I think it was the M b/c I used to enjoy making the keys make that nice satisfying sound and so I began to type far more loudly, as if each keypress was intended to make noise.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by jacobolus on Sunday June 21, 2009 @02:08AM (#667170)
They make an identical sound however hard you type, since it's caused by the instantaneous buckling of a spring.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by grandalf on Sunday June 21, 2009 @02:03PM (#667577)
true, but the keys then make a resonant sound which sounds best if you strike with a strong, swift motion.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by sketerpot on Saturday June 20, 2009 @11:02PM (#667063)
Same here (albeit with a somewhat newer model of IBM keyboard). I switched to one of the new Apple keyboards, and I've been recovering ever since. Pity the keyboard layout is so damn unusual on this thing, though. Configuring it for Linux was a real pain.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by baddox on Saturday June 20, 2009 @08:07PM (#666977)
Nostalgia is behind some of the hype, but I think durability is the bigger advantage. The sound and feel of the keys is subjective, but durability isn't. Granted, no one really needs a keyboard to last 20 years, especially at today's prices, but it's definitely impressive.
Re:Inside the World's Greatest Keyboard by dmoney on Sunday June 21, 2009 @12:24AM (#667111)
I wonder whether it's greener to build 1 keyboard like a tank or n cheap keyboards and keep replacing them.