That how our prisons should work. It may not satisfy a human being's need for retribution, but when did inflicting harm more than what's necessary to keep humans safe ever did for humanity?
Anytime you jail a human being, you're using up resources to feed them, shelter them, and protect them from dangerous human beings. That cost taxpayer money. Why not get something out of the condemned by fixing them and studying them and making them better so that the prison system will collapse because it's so effective at repairing? (Of course, there are human beings that may be unfixable, but the vast majority probably are)
I understand your point--prisons can be rehabilitative or educational institutions rather than fulfilling a purely retributive function--but your language is setting off some alarm bells for me. We ought to shift from using the language of "fixing" people to helping people or, in many cases, fixing the system.
I am also disturbed by this language. Historically, the best case for attempts to "fix" other people is that nothing happens.
The justice system in the United States used to try and "fix" the poor and the "feeble-minded" by sterilizing them. Men and women sterilized to "protect" society from them, and produce a more wonderful race.
Or perhaps we could look back to the electro-convulsive therapy and forced hormone treatment used to "fix" gay men (Alan Turing, for instance).
Turns out that sometimes it is the societies need fixing rather than the people.
Back of envelope calculation: prison population of Oklahoma:25000. Cost of meals per prisoner per day: $10. (UK hospitals budget £5 per patient per day so $10 per day is probably accurate to the nearest power of 10...). Days in year: 365.
Hence, it should come to ~$91 million if all prisoners are getting all their meals.
So we have $20 million saved by removing the greedy ones, greedy ones defined as stealing an extra meal for brekkie, din-dins and tea. So $111 million is my guestimate of how much the food bill comes to because of them scoffing their way to add $20 million on top. That would be equivalent to ~30.5k prisoners, therefore one in five of the in-mates is massively stealing extra portions every mealtime, every day.
Realistically is $10 spent per day per prisoner in Oklahoma? Sounds high to me. Would a prisoner that steals take 2 * of everything all the time, at every opportunity? They could steal more or they might steal less. So there may be more than 20% on the take for it to come to $20 million. A third of them could be habitually getting more than their allowed mealings.
Articles like this with lofty claims should have some numbers on there, rather than just pure story-interpretation. I suspect that Sysco charge a lot more than UK hospital contractors do and that they deliver a lot less. Numbers please!
> The software showed that Sysco, which supplies food to the state prison system, was charging the state different prices for the same food item sent to two different facilities,
From the linked Oklahomian article:
> “In some cases an exact same item might arrive at Lexington (Assessment and Reception Center) and Harp at the same warehouse, and one has a different price than the other,” Murphey said.
Was that a deliberate underhand move by Sysco, or is it normal expected part of contracting the job out? Or is it even more mundane, and just a price break for ordering more?
It's nice to think that there's a prison where inmates are not just allowed to rot. Here's another story where inmates get to do challenging, rewarding work looking after inmates with dementia. Warning: It contains graphic accounts of horrible violence.
http://www.nytimes.com/2012/02/26/health/dealing-with-dement...