Re:An analysis of the Adobe password dump
by xlfe on Saturday November 02, 2013 @11:05PM
(#6662031)
Thanks for the feedback.
I think it's debatable actually - while intersecting the list with another does give you less bias, it also reduces the sample size immensely (as happened in the 2011 analysis I linked to), so there are trade offs in both directions.
I'm not claiming that I know exactly how many accounts reuse passwords - I am suggesting that, based on my estimate, it is more than half.
Re:An analysis of the Adobe password dump
by Peaker on Sunday November 03, 2013 @03:01AM
(#6662558)
I don't doubt there is much password reuse. Like the original complaint, I don't think the data point has value because reusing passwords on same site implies nothing on different sites.
I think it's debatable actually - while intersecting the list with another does give you less bias, it also reduces the sample size immensely (as happened in the 2011 analysis I linked to), so there are trade offs in both directions.
I'm not claiming that I know exactly how many accounts reuse passwords - I am suggesting that, based on my estimate, it is more than half.
The evidence (that I've linked to) supports this. There are other studies which show upto 60% of password reuse: http://www.troyhunt.com/2012/07/what-do-sony-and-yahoo-have-...
If you can produce a better estimate please go ahead.