News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by sho on Saturday June 20, 2009 @12:31AM (#666134)
"Apple has previously drawn criticism from some shareholders over what they have called limited disclosure of Mr. Jobs's health problems"

"once Mr. Jobs resumes work, the company will have to be "very careful" about what it says"

This strikes me as almost unbelievably cynical, that Jobs' health could be factored into the price of Apple shares. I understand why, of course, but still, I hate it and I wonder how SJ himself feels. "Don't die yet, Steve, I'm long AAPL!"

I think he should retire soon. He's had a good run. Apple will be fine.

Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by zimbabwe on Saturday June 20, 2009 @07:48AM (#666355)
It's insane not because it's cynical, but because we've now seen twice that when Steve Jobs is gone, Apple falls back on TimCookPhilSchillerEddyCueJonathanIve and every other one of its other brilliant, beauty-minded industrialists. Jobs once said that he views Apple as his lasting triumph, not the Mac or the iPod, because with Apple he took his ideals and embedded them within the company upon his return. The result is that any one of the people at Apple is as brilliant as Jobs is. Some would argue that Tim Cook is a better Jobs than Jobs himself.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by DavidSJ on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:11AM (#666158)
How is it cynical to price the health of an organization's key person into its value?
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by anigbrowl on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:47AM (#666180)
You wait until someone's aggressively shorting DavidSJ.com.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by fallentimes on Saturday June 20, 2009 @03:26AM (#666230)
That's all part of being a public company and a negative DavidSJ accepted.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by mironathetin on Sunday June 21, 2009 @05:43PM (#667839)
Its not cynical. You don't invest in companies, you invest in their leaders.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by sho on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:34AM (#666170)
Because it's basically placing monetary bets on another human being's health. Yeah, I know he's the key person, I know why they do it, I just think it's depressing that our society still hasn't risen above putting a dollar value on life.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by gizmo on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:49AM (#666182)
Why should we rise above it? What's wrong with estimating somebody's worth in dollars?
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by jodrellblank on Saturday June 20, 2009 @10:45AM (#666450)
If I have a widget that I'll sell to you for $4 then it's worth $4 to me. If you'll only pay $2 for it then it's worth $2 to you.

To whom is a human worth money? You can't own people, can't buy or sell them. Can't recreate them, can't even get an accurate clone.

You can talk about a sportsperson's value to their team in terms of how much money they bring in in ticket sales, how much sponsorship, how much media attention, how much another team will pay for them.

But the problem is when lots of money is involved, people care more for the money than the person. I don't have a problem with people trading on Apple stock and factoring in SJ's health at some level. I do have a problem when it pushes further and further towards SJ being treated as just another asset, some legal and medical details to be pried through, some news announcements to be analysed, some blood pressure and heart rate figures to be tracking.

Picking apart the Golden Goose to try and find where the Golden Eggs are hidden? Tearing up the Mona Lisa to find which brushstroke made it worth so much? Pulling down the Eiffel tower to see if an Operah Tower in the same place would have as much impact?

If he wasn't already a health fan, would the world be pushing him to alter his diet? His exercise regime? "In a bowel movement estimated to be worth half a million dollars this morning, SJ's saturated fat absorption levels were up 13% on last week (full analysis here), SJ didn't respond to a request for comment. Unusually, he looked in the mirror for 6% longer than average over the last three months, experts have raised concerns over his increasing vanity assessment index especially when taken into account his recent announcement "I had a great night's sleep last night" to his wife over breakfast, he didn't respond to 18 phonecalls for comment on that either". Would we be designing every part of his life and forcing him to live as we think will maximise AAPL profit, restricting and shaping like a human veal calf?

What's right with estimating somebody's worth in dollars? Why should you be able to profit from speculating on someone elses work? Why should people who have no choice where they are born be forced to be judged within the limits of someone elses monetary system?

Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by gizmo on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:13PM (#666569)
It doesn't need to be that complex.

For every million dollars the government puts into hospitals/medicare a bunch of lives are saved. There are diminishing returns, however, and at some point you have to say, okay, that's enough, let's put some money into education instead.

You have to find some kind of balance, and the more you put in education the fewer lives you can save in hospitals. The only sensible way (I can think of) to find the right balance is by crunching the numbers. Saving a life for $1000? That's only 20 text books, definitely a good deal. Saving a life for a million? That's 20 scholarships. A life isn't worth that much.

Unless you're Steve.

Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by philwelch on Sunday June 21, 2009 @03:08AM (#667206)
Your comment reminds me of how much the stock market (supposedly) used to rise and fall based upon the thickness of Alan Greenspan's briefcase.

If Steve dies or retires, that's a risk to Apple. If he lives and works, that's a benefit. And the stock market relentlessly uses all information they can. The kind of private stuff you're talking about? That's insider trading, and that's why it's illegal for, say, Steve's doctor to short Apple stock based upon his medical examinations of Steve.

Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by sho on Saturday June 20, 2009 @04:16AM (#666258)
I've written and deleted about 3 attempts at answering that question, not happy with any of them and obviously I have to get my thoughts in order. It's quite the "question for the ages" : D

I'll get back to you ...

Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by gizmo on Saturday June 20, 2009 @04:29AM (#666265)
Typically, this means you have an pre-conceived opinion, and are looking for a rationalization.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by sho on Saturday June 20, 2009 @03:30PM (#666719)
Or it could mean that I have a lot of complex thoughts on the matter, and it will take some time to distil them into a pithy comment. That's the problem with rapid-fire sites like this, the pressure is on to respond quickly, before the thread sinks into oblivion - you have actually asked an interesting question and I would like to give it some thought.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by gizmo on Sunday June 21, 2009 @04:06AM (#667228)
Of course you can have complex thoughts on the matter. That's why I said "typically". I didn't make any kind of judgment. From my own experience I know that if I have an opinion but don't have the supporting arguments readily available my opinion is either wrong, or right only by coincidence. These arguments don't do well in sound-byte sized chunks though, I grant you that.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by ubernostrum on Saturday June 20, 2009 @05:12AM (#666293)
One explanation is that doing so means treating people as a means to your ends, rather than as ends in themselves. Which is somewhat frowned upon in certain ethical traditions.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by johnnybgoode on Saturday June 20, 2009 @02:17AM (#666196)
Ultimately, it's just a bunch of guesses anyway. It's not a top-down pronouncement of the value of Steve Jobs's life. If you want the theoretical case for doing this, it's supposed to assist in efficient resource allocation, which helps all of society. In other words, if we ever really "rise above" this sort of thing we'll all be poorer.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by philwelch on Saturday June 20, 2009 @06:46AM (#666334)
The value of Steve's life is incalculable, even priceless, but the value of his continued tenure at Apple indeed has a dollar value. This is what the stock market is concerned about.
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by vaksel on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:02AM (#666154)
He is only 54, plenty of things he can still do
Re:Jobs had liver transplant 2 months ago; expected to retur... by sho on Saturday June 20, 2009 @01:36AM (#666172)
Since he's already had surgery for pancreatic cancer, and now this, I wouldn't be too sure about that.