No, it would be like HackerNews blocking a 3rd party HN client that:
* Required that HackerNews trust the third party client service to provide user identity.
* Had a significantly higher level of abuse as compared to standard users.
* Required a disproportionate amount of resources to support for the given user base.
* (Least important) monetized HackerNews via advertisements.
I'm not claiming Freenode was standing to make a profit from this; you did: "* It makes money" — I also mentioned that you stand to lose money if a major network doesn't let users use your client. I'm not claiming this is your motive for wanting people to use Mibbit. I don't know what you think. Just that from an outside perspective, its a possible thought.
And I don't see the Opera comparison. Opera doesn't force users to proxy through their own servers. Its a completely transparent tool, right out of the box. Users have to actively set up a proxy for Opera to use it. With Mibbit? It uses the proxy by default, no way around it for the users.
I think that you should re-read that unless you are saying he said that Freenode "Isn't open source" as well...
We currently have WEBIRC setup with 454 IRC networks, representing around 200k users. I hardly think that's a "non standard protocol that only mibbit seems to use" is it now. All modern IRC servers support it out of the box.
I don't think I indicated freenode was planning to make a profit out of their client, you'd have to ask them about that. I wish them all the luck.
This isn't about me, or money, etc. This is about them cutting off users, who used mibbit to connect to freenode. IMHO that's a bad decision, and not a nice open friendly thing to do.
It'd be like hackernews blocking opera users if some spam submissions were submitted by opera users.