Re:Reddit’s Politics Section Bans Salon, Mother Jones, HuffP...
by baddox on Friday November 01, 2013 @06:36PM
(#6656974)
Admins and members of subreddit tend to have a slightly confused idea about what a subreddit it supposed to be. On one hand, the fundamental idea is clearly that the quality of articles is determined by the aggregate of users' votes. On the other hand, many people still appeal to some individual or objective measure of "quality," and insist that admin moderation is necessary to maintain this level of quality.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Reddit’s Politics Section Bans Salon, Mother Jones, HuffP...
by sliverstorm on Friday November 01, 2013 @06:51PM
(#6657056)
Enforcing measures of quality help subs avoid catering to the least common denominator. For example, without strict rules, /r/askscience would likely fill with many well-meaning commentators who don't actually know what they are talking about. This is bad for everyone, including those well-meaning commentators. Everyone wants the sub to be good, but that by itself isn't enough.
Re:Reddit’s Politics Section Bans Salon, Mother Jones, HuffP...
by baddox on Friday November 01, 2013 @07:46PM
(#6657349)
But by using moderation to avoid the "least common denominator," you're dealing with content that is less satisfying to users. Of course, this is only true is you judge "satisfying" by upvotes and downvotes, or perhaps other metrics like number of comments.
Re:Reddit’s Politics Section Bans Salon, Mother Jones, HuffP...
by sliverstorm on Friday November 01, 2013 @08:06PM
(#6657445)
this is only true is you judge "satisfying" by upvotes and downvotes
Right, exactly, they are saying you cannot properly (completely) judge "satisfying" by up/downvotes.