Frankly most of the patents that have been enforced seem to me at least to have been pretty minor and relatively easy to workaround with little real impact on the user.
I could see a short protection period for things like this, but the magnitude of current protections seems extreme.
But that's a somewhat different argument - the original point was that consumers were being significantly impacted and I don't think this shows that.
To my mind the biggest impact may be coming from FRAND patents, the terms of which don't have to be particularly fair or reasonable and as such can easily be used to block new entrants. To my mind FRAND patents should have transparent licensing terms which are common to every licensee whether you be a major multinational or a two man start up.