Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by rcfox on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:02AM
(#6646813)
> In fact, being good at things is a good way to get other kids to like you.
Maybe in highschool. In elementary school, having any perceived deviation from "average" is a great way to get ridiculed by the majority of kids.
Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by mrgoldenbrown on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:10AM
(#6646851)
Have you ever been in a class where you are graded on a curve? If you're the best and you ace and exam, meaning everyone else gets a C or F instead of a B, the other kids don't like you.
Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by westicle on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:25AM
(#6646945)
For those who haven't read the book, you might consider editing out your second paragraph, or at least adding spoiler tags.
Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by moron4hire on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:48AM
(#6647082)
For a book that is nearly 30 years old? SPOILERS: King Kong dies at the end and the Titanic sinks at the end.
Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by talmand on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:12AM
(#6647240)
I agree, because new generations never watch old movies or read old books for the first time.
Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by moron4hire on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:10PM
(#6647633)
There is more to a book than the end. Just because you know what happens in general doesn't mean you can't enjoy reading the book at all. Why do people re-read books? Why do people watch movies based on books, or go back and read the book after they've seen the movie?
I'm not going to destroy my prose with legalistic gerrymandering just because you're too emotionally underdeveloped to enjoy a story after knowing details about it.
Re:The 'Unfilmable' Ender's Game’s 28 Years in Development Hell
by talmand on Thursday October 31, 2013 @02:05PM
(#6648510)
Wow, defensive much? By your logic you should be fine with reading a book backwards. That may be your bag but not everyone would agree.
I reread and rewatch stuff all the time. That doesn't mean I want to know how the story ends the very first time I'm exposed to it.
I think you're too emotionally underdeveloped to realize I didn't ask you to destroy your prose with legalistic gerrymandering in the first place.
I likewise did not enjoy the book as an adult reader. I thought it was far to apologetic for ultraviolent, genocidal overreactions to be considered healthy reading for teenagers. The end of the book is not "genocide is bad". It's "isn't is a shame that poor Ender had to be tricked into committing genocide?" It's not that "governments shouldn't be given the sort of power capable of genocide", it's that "you can get away with it scott-free if your intentions were good."
Also, the whole "they hate me because I'm the best" wore really thin on me. It's just not a thing you see amongst real kids. In fact, being good at things is a good way to get other kids to like you. The kids didn't like Ender because he was a self-righteous prick, a spoil-sport punk with a Napoleon complex.
The dialog also sucked. Grade A shitty dialog. As a teenager, you might be intrigued by the idea of alternative slang (and that is probably why Buffy the Vampire Slayer was so popular, and by extension why Joss Whedon has such a following now, but can't seem to follow it up). But as an adult, it is really annoying.