News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by cubancigar11 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:41AM (#6645768)
Interest in humanities is fading because humanities have failed the world. Instead of understanding the society and bringing about some positive change, they have become a tool for cultural domination. Some even say that the role of humanities, and history teaching, has always been about cultural domination.

But the idea of cultural domination is anathema to most of the 'new generation' which relies, rather, depends on cultural assimilation and tolerance in this global economy for their bread and butter. And this change hasn't come due to humanities... it has come due to technological revolution. So, of course, the interest in humanities is fading.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by Qom on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:30AM (#6646174)
That's a rather extreme viewpoint. Don't forget that it's things like culture that make life worth living. I love technology, but I also recognize that the end goal of technological progress is to allow us to experience more culture by augmenting and facilitating our lives.

I honestly don't see how studying Ancient Greek for example is supposed to encourage cultural domination. The term "humanities" denotes a vast array of subjects.

If there is cultural domination going on, it's mostly with the mass media output of whichever country happens to be in a position of power at the time. For instance, the US have been flooding the market for a long while with their audio, video and written content thanks to their dominant economic position. Local production simply cannot compete with billion-dollar budgets. This leads to cultural intoxication in millions of minds around the world as they are exposed every day to the American way of viewing the world and American cultural norms. A humanities course, no matter how active in its propaganda, cannot possibly rival this kind of utter cultural domination.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by chrismonsanto on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:01AM (#6646506)
> but I also recognize that the end goal of technological progress is to allow us to experience more culture by augmenting and facilitating our lives

For you, anyway. For me (a theoretical computer scientist/mathematician), more advanced technology is its own reward. I don't really care what the results are applied to.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by Qom on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:29AM (#6646968)
Expanding our understanding of the universe IS part of culture since it allows us new avenues of thought. The arts and sciences were considered to be the same thing not so long ago.

I also find it highly doubtful that you do not care about the results of technology. Technology pretty much shapes our lives so you cannot plausibly pretend to be so blasé about it all. Our continued existence depends on the responsible use of powerful inventions so not caring about the results is a pretty unscientific and downright dangerous attitude anyway.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by jtheory on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:16AM (#6645851)
Can you offer any more concrete specifics? I studied humanities in college (primarily music, some English lit and creative writing, some French lit, ancient Eastern philosophy, etc. -- also compsci, but mostly humanities), and it was something of a mixed bag as educations go, but I did build some very valuable communication and thinking skills along the way.

I'm not at all clear how especially something like studying ancient Chinese philosophers could fit into your generalizations, but regardless -- mastering communication and clear thinking on complex, diverse topics is hugely valuable in almost any endeavor, and I've encountered some shamefully poor communicators (and unclear thinkers) in the tech world.

I suspect if the humanities could successfully focus on good outcomes in these categories, and demonstrate the value, they'd benefit from it... somehow blending in applied rationality with the standard paths would be awesome, and if that were available I'd go that route again, if I had the choice again.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by cubancigar11 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:30AM (#6646035)
You have given good examples yourself. Before the acceptance of French into humanities, it was just a language evolving with its speakers. After that it was given the status of "official", with official grammar to maintain purity. But who decided which vernacular was pure and which wasn't? The powers that be. The privileged noble who had time for it. While it resulted in better economic opportunities for everyone (while requiring no effort from those who already spoke the pure form), it also quashed the cultural diversity.

English is another example. People in most of the world learn British English, simply because English was taught to them when British ruled them because they wanted to create a English speaking cheap workforce. Now that British are gone, their legacy remains. For example, Shakespeare is still mandatory to learn in India, and novels that are today confined to humanities in Britain, are most read in India - they don't read catcher in the rye, they read The Tempest and The Woman in White etc. You can see that firsthand - Indians use idioms that long ago fell out of use in Britain. "Please do the needful" anyone? "I was doing that only"? This is not just about Indians. Germans, as I have been told, learn UK English in school. But eventually all their clients are American, so they end up learning American vernacular and spellings. They can't be blamed, every default is American now.

Coming to Eastern philosophy, consider this: the earth is round, people are equal so how come there is something called East or West. It is arbitrary! It is THE example of grouping and stereotypes[1]. There is a large branch of sociology and history dealing with this idea.[2] I will leave it at that since this is closer to my heart and thus I am prone to be biased. Plus, I am still reading more about it.

The idea is not that Chinese philosophers would fit in my description or not, the idea is that the philosophers you call Chinese are just a sect of a philosophers in China. But when first non-Chinese went into China, their interest wasn't in philosophy but in the money Chinese had. Through that economical agent they measured everything that was there - the economically weak Chinese philosophers were neglected and forgotten into history and the official Chinese doctrine accepted as the one true 'Chinese'. "Because that is what makes them different." It is why when China dabbles into modernism we call them copycats and not just coming to equal terms. They HAVE to be different, right?

I went overboard, I suppose. I am not a good writer nor a native English speaker. Indian, actually. Regarding music, I think it should belong to science and mathematics :)

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Ingroup

2. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orientalism

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by JetSetWilly on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:21AM (#6646345)
> Germans, as I have been told, learn UK English in school. But eventually all their clients are American, so they end up learning American vernacular and spellings.

Eh?

The UK is a very large trading partner of Germany.

German exports to UK 2012:73 Billion euro

German exports to US 2012:87 Billion euro

German global exports: 1095 Billion

So, please. Who's the imperialist and marginaliser now? The US accounts for just 7.9% of german exports, so "most of their clients" abroad - rubbish.

It is deeply ironic that you're complaining about foreigners studying classics of British English, while contrasting with classics from American English as though that would be an obviously superior and more rational choice.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by jtheory on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:03AM (#6646522)
You were arguing that the humanities were a tool for cultural domination, though, that cultural domination was somehow among (or even the main) role of humanities studies.

My examples don't show that the humanities have any role in exacerbating the reality of some cultures dominating others, though. How does it help cultural domination if American, Christian students learn that none of Jesus' ideas were actually original to him?

Certainly, East/West is arbitrary, as is whether "North" is on top of the globe or on the bottom (an inverted globe is just as valid). You can study things like this in the humanities, whereas you'll never even think about them if you take a technical track. You even mention above that there are large branches of sociology and history dealing with this -- so are the humanities enforcing Orientalism, or actually combating it?

Final point, though it's more minor - about this:

> Before the acceptance of French into humanities, it was just a language evolving with its speakers. After that it was given the status of "official", with official grammar to maintain purity. But who decided which vernacular was pure and which wasn't? The powers that be. The privileged noble who had time for it. While it resulted in better economic opportunities for everyone (while requiring no effort from those who already spoke the pure form), it also quashed the cultural diversity.

See the Académie française (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Acad%C3%A9mie_fran%C3%A7aise) -- French has not been a language evolving naturally with its speakers since the 1630s. There certainly are external forces pushing the French to adopt more loanwords like "email" and so on, but what's cause would you point to for that? Surely not French literature and language programs in other countries...? If anything, me studying Camus and Voltaire introduces more French speakers who use classical French, rather than adopting to a naturally-evolving language (in spite of the Académie française...).

Honestly, this is part of what I mean about learning to support a reasonable argument. It's not effective to construct examples to "support" a point you've already committed to. You'll do better taking a reasonably representative set of specific examples of a phenomenon, discarding your earlier assumptions, and look for the best explanation. That's your new starting point.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by cubancigar11 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:57PM (#6651693)
> <i>Honestly, this is part of what I mean about learning to support a reasonable argument. It's not effective to construct examples to "support" a point you've already committed to.</i> Point taken.

As I said, I am still reading and since the subject is close to me I tend to run into my own biases.

<i> > so are the humanities enforcing Orientalism, or actually combating it?</i> I am not a Marxist who believes every odd thing is intentional. But I do believe that humanities aren't as critical to The System as they are portrayed to be. They are very well an integral part of The System. And The System is all about money which humanities don't bring any more - hence the decreasing interest. For example, science is about pursuit of pure knowledge, but then most of its funding comes from DARPA, isn't it? So, in a peaceful world, scientific pursuit WILL dwindle. That is just the fact. Whether intentional or consequential, or whether science wants to bring peace or not, those questions are beyond my understanding as of now. And I think they will remain conjectural even after my death.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by jccalhoun on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:47AM (#6646449)
I'm a grad student in the humanities so I have a vested interest but I would say that your comment may apply to some humanities but it is also the humanities that is where people are exploring the negatives of cultural domination and the value of diversity.

I'm in media studies and use cultural studies, gender studies, and anthropology (which likes to claim it is a "science" but I don't really consider it one). Those fields along with things like post-colonial studies are all about examining and tearing down the systems of cultural domination.

As someone who got my BA in English, I find it difficult to understand why some humanities departments are as large as they are at large research universities. Literacy and literature are very important but I don't know that we should be churning out very many people with phds in English.

Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by cubancigar11 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:41PM (#6651638)
Yes, true. The role of humanities is not as hard-cut as I probably sound in my previous comment. It is indeed a virtue to be able to self-judge. I suppose one can say that humanities is now a mature field which has hit its natural plateau, kind of like classical thermodynamics.
Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by cubancigar11 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:58AM (#6645808)
Why the down vote?
Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by ars on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:04AM (#6645823)
I didn't, but I'm guess because people don't think it causes cultural domination. I think most people think humanities doesn't do anything at all.
Re:As Interest Fades in the Humanities, Colleges Worry by cubancigar11 on Thursday October 31, 2013 @05:23AM (#6645870)
Well, I did say 'some' :)

The people with no interest in Humanities will not take humanities anyway. That the interest in humanities is decreasing points directly to the fact that people who actually _like_ humanities are disenchanted with it. That is who my comment is referring to. There is a whole literature in sociology dealing with relationship between humanities and colonialism[1].

But I suppose people downvoting me have really got no interest in humanities :) Apparently, anything that makes it look like it might have a value must be bad.

1. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Orientalism