News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:20PM (#6641278)
As a pianist I do not understand the purpose of music that is not playable by humans. In my understanding music is a communication method between human souls. A computer has no soul, likewise Black MIDI "music".
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by PavlovsCat on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:59PM (#6641962)
Obligatory quote:

"If I hear one more person who comes up to me and complains about "computer music has no soul" then I will go furious, you know. 'Cause of course the computer is just a tool. And if there is no soul in computer music then it's because nobody put it there and that's not the computer's role. It's the role of the songwriter. He puts down his soul in the song if he wants to. A guitar will never write a song and a computer will never write a song. These are just tools." -- Björk

That said, I'm not a fan of those particular songs either; less would be more IMHO. But many of my all time favourite songs are chip tunes... some compositions (!) simply don't need additional "soul" added to them, they work just fine played by a robot.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by mrgoldenbrown on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:39PM (#6641388)
This music is "playable by humans." Their instrument is a MIDI sequencer rather than a piano or guitar. Are you claiming that only X, Y and Z physical artifacts can make real music? Do player pianos make music? Does my MP3 player output music? Maybe I'm unsophisticated, but plenty of 'music' that comes out of my MP3 player generates the kind of emotion that I think of when you say "communication between souls".
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by aegiso on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:51PM (#6641469)
As an internet commenter I do not understand the purpose of Wifi signals that are not visible to humans. In my understanding discussion is a communication method between human souls. A computer has no soul, likewise Internet "comments".
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by Strilanc on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:40PM (#6641396)
Pianos don't have souls, either.

Maybe I'd understand your complaint if it was about computer composition of music, but this is just using the computer as an instrument. Would you say flute players can't play music "with soul" because they aren't directly whistling the noises? Why not? How is that qualitatively different from using a computer to play your composition?

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:51PM (#6641907)
Handmade Pianos have souls. The soul of the technician that built it. This is why the best Pianos like Bösendorfer and Steinways are still built manually.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by PavlovsCat on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:08PM (#6642023)
That sounds kind of esoteric / superstitious to me. Has this been blind tested? Anyway... computer music has the soul of the people selecting the samples and the parameters for instrument synthesis, and choosing when and how to play them. That's why all that is done manually. Heck, on the C64 (probably not just there) it wasn't unusual for composers to write their own composing software and playback routines.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:21PM (#6642126)
In the C64 days I programmed my TI99/4A to play Bach. It sounded awful. The interpretation had no soul.

Soul is not blind testable, like art, because it comes from the heart, not the brain.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by Stwerp on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:52PM (#6642385)
Is soul the imprecision of notes not being perfectly uniform in duration and velocity? That's what your above comment seems to imply.

For instance: Consider a recording from a piano played by a human and a computer-generated MIDI file of the same musical piece with included variation/noise in BPM, note duration, velocity, timing etc.

This would result in at least single-blind test for `soul' if you were to listen to it. You could tell us which piece you think has more, or any (I'm not sure if soul is quantifiable or just a binary existence) soul.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by pit on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:15PM (#6643018)
What about a recording versus a live performance? Isn't a MIDI essentially a super-low-resolution digital recording, minus any spatial acoustic noise? Is soul then contained in space, or the presence of those souls present?

Here's an idea for a test: start with a song recorded at 44100Hz (standard CD quality) that has soul. We can debate the actual piece of music, but I'll use "Clap Your Hands" by A Tribe Called Quest in this example. Give a bunch of people a randomly-downsampled version of the song (at 12500Hz, 800Hz, 220Hz, etc), and have them answer a simple question: "Does this have soul?"

The song is 93BPM, or 1.55 beats per second. At a sample rate of 1.55Hz, we're looking at one sample per beat. Let's use a standard 16-step sequencer and say that a MIDIfied approximation is going to have four samples per beat (quarter notes). So, at about 6.2Hz, we've got a recording that has no better resolution than MIDI (potentially even worse).

Ultimately, I guess I agree with you: "soul" is in the ear of the beholder.

(Disclaimer: I don't actually know anything about digital audio.)

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:12PM (#6642538)
No soul, is not imprecision. It is the expression of humans feelings in form of variation of duration, velocity, loudness. For example speed in music is like speed in breathing. You are not breathing with the same speed all the time. It depends on the context. If you are in a hurry you breathe fast and short. If you sigh you breathe deep and slow. An interpret has to understand the emotions that should be transported. These emotions are unfortunately not sufficiently presentable in MIDI files or music notation. As Mahler said the essence of music is not in the sheet. Therefore a computer can not reproduce the essence of music.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by PavlovsCat on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:22PM (#6643085)
> Therefore a computer can not reproduce the essence of music.

Music that wasn't written on and for a computer, no. Yet it's perfectly possible to manually craft "variation of duration, velocity, loudness" for every single note of every single instrument -- just not by feeding music in standard musical notation into a sequencer unchanged! I agree that MIDI isn't very sophisticated, but it's hardly the last word of music written on and played back by computers. Just consider how young this all is! I'm pretty sure physical instruments and the songs played on them started out kinda simplicistic, too. And tribal music for example often isn't so much about expression emotion, but putting people into a trance-like state by endless repetition, and techno does that just nicely already. It's not my cup of tea generally, but I get the same out of chip tunes: I don't need sophisticated music, I just need a canvas for my ears and soul to draw on, I can fill in the blanks or dream up harmonies on my own.

> An interpret has to understand the emotions that should be transported.

True, but also

a.) it doesn't stop there. Beauty is in the eye of the beholder, and if a simple "gridlike" composition makes me sad, happy or gives me goosebumps, that's "soul enough" for me. Even the soul of a simpleton is still a soul :)

b.) the computer enables composer and interpret to be the same person.. and if they so desire, they can put endless amounts of detail and emotion into a piece. Personally I have no doubt that people like Mozart would have been all over computers as an instrument, and the wide range of expression they offer already.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @05:19PM (#6643484)
The problem lies in the context. If we speak to each other we take human context into account. So does a musical interpret. It is just another medium. Music instead of words. A computer does not understand human context. This has already be proven by Weizenbaum with his program Eliza. If the Computer does not understand emotion, he does not understand how to create music. There is no possibility to formalize music exactly, so that a computer can play it accordingly. I doubt that this will ever be possible because a true artist takes human context into account in his performance. So there is no static formalization of music. The only solution would be that the composer plays live on the computer. But an instrument that can not be played by humans is useless in this situation.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by PavlovsCat on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @06:33PM (#6643950)
With computer music, the act of composition and the act of playing it are one and the same. It's like writing a piece, having an orchestra play it, then going back to the score sheet and changing something, over and over. Usually at some point time, patience and/or inspiration run out, long before the song is really good -- but that's a limitation of the state of the art(ists), not of music made with computers in general, IMHO.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:22AM (#6645398)
No it is not. There is no orchestra. There is an context less, static description of tones, called sheet music or MIDI. These description gets transformed to music whenever a musician plays it or to a set of soulless notes if a computer plays it.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by PavlovsCat on Thursday October 31, 2013 @03:12AM (#6645605)
As I said already, MIDI is kind of crude and hardly the last word. The description can be as detailed as the brain of the composer can handle it. The acts of composition and performance are indistinguishable. You could even manually set the amplitude of 44100 (or more) points per second if you wanted to... arguably the musicians that can make full use of the possibilities that exist even now haven't even been born yet.

Someone else made a very good point about paintings, and you kind of missed it by saying computers can't paint like Da Vinci or Shakespeare -- of course they can't, just like a brush or a pencil can't, and just like a piano can't compose. Do reprints of Shakespeare's work have soul in your opinion? And do they have more, less, or just as much soul than exact reproductions of his original handwriting? Is it possible to communicate soul by typing as we do right now, or would we have to see and smell the hands doing the typing for that, and heads pausing in reflection? Can a photo made with a DSLR and tweaked in a RAW converter have soul? Can a big format analogue photograph? What resolution does soul have, what resolution does our perception of it have? If facial expressions convey soul, does imperfection of sight reduce the amount of soul being communicated? Why does a piano piece that can move one human deeply leave another completely cold? Why can a landscape, even one devoid of plants and animals, make the soul sing, why does soul get perceived where none was put into? If it's because God created it, how does this not apply to computers as well? So many questions ^^

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:12AM (#6647243)
He's making a more fundamental mistake, borne by his lack of emotional range.

He's arguing that every poem cannot have a soul, only during the recitation of a poem, by a live performer, can the work take on the kind of soulful meaning.

Yet this criteria, a human must perform art for it to have a soul, eliminates all non-performance art. Painting, sculpture, etc. all has no soul.

Yet this is obviously not true. A great painting has soul just as much as any other art.

So what happens when you have a poem, crafted as a sculpture? We've already determined that sculptures have a "soul", therefore something like this http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_GIchwvJ-aNk/SxMre-2FXnI/AAAAAAAANW... has a soul, but no human performed it. The emotional connection is made via the writer and the sculpture (who may even be the same person). Yet, no human can "perform" this sculpture.

In cases like the OP, the music we have here is no different than a sculpture of the composer's intention. No human performs it, yet it's no less valid than if it was written down for an orchestra of painists to perform.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:28PM (#6647759)
Do you know and understand the painting "This is not a pipe" by Margritte?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:59PM (#6651368)
That painting hangs in pretty much every independent coffee shop and cafe in probably 50 countries.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @01:17AM (#6651922)
Great, and what does it mean?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Friday November 01, 2013 @03:30AM (#6652351)
You've got to be kidding me. It means it's a painting, not an actual pipe. And by extension, other representational art is not what it represents but something else. But it doesn't matter to you, because the painting is not being performed by a human, and is the same every time you look at it, therefore it, you claim, it doesn't have a soul.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @06:43AM (#6652883)
A painting exists to moment it is drawn and it is persistent more or less for at least a few hundred years. Music on the other hand is ordered vibration of air molecules (and this is something different than a composition, hence the pipe example). These vibrations are vanishing immediately. Therefore a painting does not have to be performed like music.

Every form of human art has a soul, a painting, or the actually played music. Computer made "art" does not have a soul, although it may have the same physical structure than a human made one.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:13AM (#6645994)
We are talking about MIDI sequences that are not producible by humans. If no human can produce those sequences, how can they have human soul?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:06AM (#6647197)
Yes it is. The orchestra is the computer.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:20PM (#6647705)
You say that a computer is equivalent to an orchestra?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:58PM (#6651365)
I say that an old washboard and a bucket of nails can be the equivalent of an orchestra. A computer is no different an instrument in a musicians hands than any other instrument.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @01:20AM (#6651931)
My only possible conclusion of your saying is that you have never heard a good big orchestra.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Friday November 01, 2013 @03:33AM (#6652356)
I've played in 2 good big orchestras, 1 nationally ranked. I've even been section lead of one and concert master of an orchestra and a Baroque chamber group. I don't consider myself a great musician, but I definitely know that you've puffed your mind up with so much bullshit you could open a fertilizer plant.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @06:46AM (#6652889)
If those orchestras sounded like a old washboard and a bucket of nails, than I definitely do not want to attend a concert.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:03AM (#6647180)
> duration, velocity, loudness

Then harpsichords have no soul and Bach would like to have a word with you.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @08:11PM (#6650997)
It is known that Bach improvised about his works during performances. That means he even left the written notes.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:00PM (#6651372)
A harpsichord pretty much fails your "test" for "instruments with souls".
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @01:21AM (#6651934)
why?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Friday November 01, 2013 @03:33AM (#6652359)
I told you two comments ago, you also don't have any reading comprehension. Do you know what a harpsichord is and how it works?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @06:35AM (#6652858)
Timing is the most important thing in Music according to Mozart. Are you trying to say that a harpsichord does not allow variations of timing?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vidarh on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:53AM (#6646773)
And all your experience tells us is that the Ti99/4A did not have good sound chips and/or you are not good at writing music for it. Meanwhile, I still listen to certain C64 music regularly that I greatly enjoy, because the composer knew how to extract great music even from something as limited as that.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:27AM (#6647346)
No, the TI99/4A had no understanding of music. You have to have emotions to understand music. A Computer does not have emotions.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by tesseractive on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @05:21PM (#6643494)
So does that mean that piano music played on an insufficiently fancy piano is soulless as well?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @05:34PM (#6643574)
I have a Kawai MP10 digital Piano and an old hand made analog Hofmann piano. If I play for example just the last Chord (6 Notes) of Chopin Prelude op. 28/4 on the Hofmann the music goes deep through every nerve. Nothing comparable happens on the Kawai even with very good speakers.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by yongjik on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @07:11PM (#6644147)
That's what people who buy monster ethernet cables say.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by tesseractive on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @05:50PM (#6643659)
Are you saying that those 2 data points constitute a spanning set of the possibilities?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:33PM (#6650833)
Do you understand the concept of a example?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:40AM (#6645270)
Bad musicians frequently blame the instruments.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:18AM (#6645390)
You mean good musicians do not distinguish good and bad instruments?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:45AM (#6645459)
A good musician can play world class music on a rusty spoon, a used pie plate and a one-string-out-of-tune-$20-guitar.

Crap musicians are those that rely on fancy instruments to make up for their lack of basic musicianship.

Even a drunk martini bar pianist can sound halfway decent on a $70k Steinway or Bösendorfer.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @03:39AM (#6645658)
I do not doubt that. But to return to the original point, a good instrument has a soul, as a good musician has. My digital-Kawai does not have one, my analog Hofmann has. My musical skills have nothing to do with that.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:40AM (#6647039)
The nature of the instrument doesn't dictate its soul. A digital piano was made with just as much care and soul as a regular old piano.

Even instruments with very limited expressiveness are no less important. Yanni regularly brings listeners to tears and he plays as much on a synth as he does on a traditional piano.

"Soulfulness" didn't stop with the digital revolution. You're simply no sophisticated enough to perceive it. Even instruments like a tb303 have brought deep meaning, and communicated emotional soulful intention, to millions.

Your emotional range is just too narrow to feel it. Blame yourself not the instruments.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:23AM (#6647306)
Have you ever played a Bösendorfer Imperial?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @04:04PM (#6649384)
Yes. I can do you one better, I've even played the piano discussed here

http://www.nytimes.com/2003/03/03/international/europe/03RUS...

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @07:39PM (#6650852)
If you can not understand the difference between these instruments and a for example a Kawai MP10 than any discussion is meaningless.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:02PM (#6651379)
I've also played wooden spoons, a TB-303, TR-808, TR-909, Classical Violin, Appalachian fiddle, Classical Cello, Classical Piano, Piano Moderne, Three kinds of Organ, Several Synths, Tracker, Marimba, Xylophone, 북, 장고, Kazoo, Slide Whistle, Pot and Pan, 5-gallon drum, Hang, Recorder (modern and classical), flute, penny whistle, Appalachian dulcimer, Hammered Dulcimer, 꽹과리, 자바라, and on and on and on. I'm not even uniquely qualified to comment on this because music is a universe, not a spectrum.

If you can't create beautiful, soulful, music on a Kawai MP10, or even a bag or sand, then I question your authority on music. You rely on expensive instruments as crutches to fill in your musicality, when you need to develop your own. Start with simple instruments and when you can put soul into a pair of wooden spoons then you can move on to more expressive instruments.

Somebody who can't perform with soul on a Kawai MP10, then any discussion is more than meaningless because you've limited soulful musicality to such a tiny fraction of music and instruments in the world that you definition is effectively useless.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @01:16AM (#6651915)
I did not say that I can not perform on a MP10. I regularly do, because of practical reasons. All I said is that the Hofmann or any other hand made piano is much better because it has a soul. Just look in the worlds concert halls and see what word class classical pianists prefer.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Friday November 01, 2013 @03:36AM (#6652365)
Because they require less performance effort to get a nice sound, not because they have a soul.

Your argument is like saying "chefs use better ingredients in their restaurant then at home because those ingredients have a soul, while the ingredients they use for home cooking does not".

You are utterly divorced from any reality and live in a trite pedantic fantasy world. Please stop talking to me.

You're simultaneously tiring, limited and boring.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @06:32AM (#6652851)
No chefs use better ingredients because that leads to better tasting food. As music is a communication method of emotions from human to human, a better instrument is one that leverages emotions. Hand made instruments are far better in this regard than robots or computers because the idea of sound of the craftsman, and therefore his soul and emotions, are built in. That is why hand made instruments sounds far more different to each other than modern CNC made pianos. The hand made ones have personality and taste. Important ingredients for good music.

Do you think there is only one (your) reality in the world?

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vidarh on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:45PM (#6641430)
I don't get that mindset at all. A lot of the music I listen to is music that is not playable on an analogue instruments without severely butchering it.

Ranging from 8-bit chip tunes to much more complex electronic music.

Why does that affect the level of communication? To me, the only thing that is different vs a song is that for electronic music the communication is mostly from the composer. But I find that to be the case for most instrumental music, including classical music - a performer that adds so much "personality" to the piece that I notice will generally annoy me.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:30PM (#6642194)
A human interpretation of sheet music is a 3 tier soul transformation. Composer - Interpret - Listener. Computer played music has an digital filter that eliminates a lot of soul in between.

Music notation is only a recipe for making music. Playing the recipe is not making music.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by MoosePlissken on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:41PM (#6642790)
There are plenty of other artistic mediums that lack a performance aspect. Painting, drawing, literature, photography. Do these mediums also lack soul because they directly connect the composer to the audience, without a third party to interpret? Sure, if a piece of music was written with the intent that it be played by human hands, then it probably won't sound great when played by a computer. But if an artist creates an original piece of music using electronic tools, how is listening to that piece any different than viewing a photograph, a painting, or reading a book? Many people dislike audio books specifically BECAUSE the filter of the narrator colors their interpretation of the author's words. As with reading, one might argue that electronic music better communicates the author's soul to the audience.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @05:29PM (#6643541)
A computer can not paint like Leonardo Da Vinci. He can not write like Shakespeare. And he can not play music like Sviatlosav Richter.

A prush, pencil, and musical instrument that can not be used by humans is therefore useless.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vidarh on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:40AM (#6646706)
Your premise and your conclusion is entirely unconnected by any form of logic.

The point of the post you reply to is that art can be created even when it is not possible or meaningful to do it as a live performance. Performers do not have a monopoly on creating art. In fact, sometimes performers are props that are or have been necessary due to the lack of technology.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:52AM (#6646767)
Music does not exist until the moment it is played. Therefore you need the performance to create art out of a composition. Computers can not create art.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vidarh on Thursday October 31, 2013 @10:10AM (#6646857)
I don't agree with your premise. The composition as much art, often more so, than the performance. For most of the music I listen to, including the classical music, I want the performance to be a faithful reproduction of the intention of the composition. For sheet music, you need the performer to interpret, but if he or she interprets outside of well established norms, the piece will sound off.

For electronic compositions rendered directly to a sufficiently precise format (which MIDI is not), you need no separate performance - the act of composing it and performing it is the same.

Since I reject your premise, your conclusion is irrelevant to me, and I don't think there's any chance we will get any further.

I see from other comments that you imbue the touch of a human performer some special quality beyond the qualities purely physical sound generated, and to me that is pure superstition with no basis in reality. You might as well try to convince me fairies are real.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:20AM (#6647286)
Do you play an analog instrument?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vidarh on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:34AM (#6646658)
No, but creating the recipe is making music.

You are assuming that more "soul" (whatever you mean by that) is better. I argue that often it is worse: I tend to dislike classical music where the person playing the music adds too much personal flair (or "soul"), because it makes it sound different to what I expect the piece to sound like. To me that added "soul" detracts from the experience more often than it adds. For that reason too, I organize my classical music solely by composer: If the performing artist is "too noticeable" for me, the piece won't stay in my library, and so I have no interest in who the performer is for the classical albums I keep playing (yes, I can hear the cries in agony from people who considers the performer important).

And electronically generated music is not sheet music. It is more akin to a recording of a performance, even if that "recording" was not live. It embodies what the composer intended the piece to be, rather than being a mix of a recipe from the composer and a musicians interpretation of that recipe. And I am perfectly fine with not having someone else meddling with the composers vision.

(I do listen to a lot of remixes, and that is different in that they are different enough to the originals to be separate works that I can enjoy that separate expression).

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Friday November 01, 2013 @08:28AM (#6653206)
Then you definitely would not like to hear Bach or Mozart themselves playing their own works. It is well known that those improvised on their own works during performances.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @12:53AM (#6645320)
You're making the fundamental mistake that all notes that are written down are the same. A midi-file isn't a score, it's a recording of the playback of notes. A performer can sit down at a midi enabled Steinway Grand and record their performance into a midi file, then they can play back that exact performance on the same piano and it will sound identical to the original. If you were to listen to such a playback with your back turned, you would be unable to tell if the pianist was playing, or if the midi was.

Programming a machine to play something back in just the way the composer wanted is the same as performance. The composer get to become the performance artist interpreting and setting their own will, their "soul" as you want to call it, into the machine. So that their music is interpreted and heard exactly as they wished it to be. It's no different than if the composer were to perform their own compositions.

You may not like the instrument being used here, or the way in which the composer has expressed their intent in the recording, but it's exactly as they intended.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:40AM (#6645447)
The OP mentioned MIDI music that is not playable by humans.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @01:47AM (#6645466)
So? It doesn't mean the composer can't write music that exceeds the ability of any human performer and still encode the nuance they intended into the performance.

Just because I can't humanly play Paganini's Caprices doesn't mean it's bad music.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:17AM (#6646005)
If the composer writes music that is not even playable by himself, then this music is never played by a human. Therefore a soul to soul communication to the listener is impossible.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by Flenser on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:10AM (#6646548)
I challenge John Williams to play the theme to Star Wars on his own! The point bane is trying to make is that the composer can use MIDI to record parts of a performance and then combine it into a form which is then unplayable by a single person [Edit: or any group of people].
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by vidarh on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:50AM (#6646761)
I don't even know what a "soul to soul communication" is intended to mean. It sounds like you are applying some mystic qualities to it. I think most of us here don't think that the act of performance itself adds anything to the quality of the sound of the music over and beyond the sounds that are recorded, and so a "recording" that is painstakingly generated note by note is to me no different from one that is played live as long as they sound the same. If a piece has never, ever been played live, it makes no difference to me.

This "soul to soul communication" you talk of has no meaning to me.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bane on Thursday October 31, 2013 @11:00AM (#6647158)
99.999% of composers write music they don't and can't play themselves. That's why techniques like this are appealing, because the composer can write the performance at the same time. The written music is the performance. There's no obtuse performer screwing up the composer's will in this scenario.

You have a fundamentally broken concept about music.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by wonderyak on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @02:42PM (#6642305)
Zappa referred to electronic music (of the day) as 'missing the eyebrows'. Its sort of the uncanny valley of electronic music.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by neuralk on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:50PM (#6641467)
When you say "playable by humans," what do you mean?

If you mean "physically capable of being played by a human" then I'd say that a large majority of popular music right now is unplayable by humans, simply due to the sheer amount of digital production that goes into them. Many genres of electronic music fit in this category, but while being "unplayable," all clearly have an author (the composer/producer) and an intent (no matter how shallow or profound).

But if you meant "playable by humans" on a subtler level, I then ask:

Is music coming from a radio playable by humans? Is music written on a sheet playable by humans? Both lack an immediate human operator that is "playing" them, yet despite this difference of media, both are valid forms of music that clearly communicate the intent of a human soul (the former through the radio device, the latter through symbols).

I'd argue that using the computer/algorithm used to generate the black MIDI is an instrument like any other. Maybe you were asking something more along the lines of: how valuable is music that is generated arbitrarily or randomly by a computer algorithm, and does it contain "soul" like music produced explicitly by humans? That is a philosophical question about the nature of art and computational creativity, perhaps without an answer.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by holri on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @01:48PM (#6641883)
As Frank Zappa said music notation is like a recipe. He also said eating the recipe is crazy. Hearing computer played notes is like eating the recipe.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by secoif on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:30PM (#6641336)
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by bradleyland on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:36PM (#6641371)
If music is communication that originates in your soul, then your hands are merely a tool for realizing that expression. Why can't music realized through other means have soul? Arguably, more complex tools allow for greater expressiveness.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by cdcarter on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:38PM (#6641380)
Go see a Nicolas Jaar concert, or any other incredible electronic musician, and then please tell me again that electronic music has no soul.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by owenmarshall on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:25PM (#6641311)
Interesting take. What's your impression of Musique concrète or - possibly the furthest out - someone like Cage?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by owenmarshall on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:10AM (#6646553)
I just want to point out how depressing it is that a comment that has spawned quite a bit of interesting discussion has been downvoted so heavily.

C'mon HN, be better than that!

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by kalleboo on Thursday October 31, 2013 @06:19AM (#6646011)
Some of my favorite music is VOCALOID-based (musical speech synthesis), so it doesn't even have a real person singing. And it sure as hell has a lot more "soul" that a lot of the music that's been played by "real instruments" (especially your extremely slim definition).
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by peterpathname on Thursday October 31, 2013 @09:13AM (#6646565)
recommendations?
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by 21echoes on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:52PM (#6641479)
this is like saying books must be spoken aloud, never written down.
Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by normloman on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:57PM (#6641513)
Ordinary people like music that sounds good. They don't care how it was made. Only musicians care about that.

So whether it was made by human hands or a computer algorithm, if it sounds good, people will listen.

Re:The Impossible Music of Black MIDI by derleth on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @12:49PM (#6641458)
I'm pretty certain I don't have a soul, either.