News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ryan Carson responds to Paul Graham on startup hubs by danw on Thursday October 11, 2007 @02:38PM (#66392)
I think Ryan and PG have a different idea of what startups are. PG said in response to a question at FOWA that he was talking about startups designed for acquisition by the likes of Google. Acquisition is much easier where there are big established companies to network with. Ryan on the other hand seems to be talking about bootstrapping and building to last, which doesn't depend on the benefits of SV as much.
Re:Ryan Carson responds to Paul Graham on startup hubs by pg on Thursday October 11, 2007 @06:13PM (#66551)
I certainly did not say that. What I said was that if there was no exit, it wasn't a startup. IPO is also a form of exit.

But the conclusion here is also false: you need bold and intelligent investors even more to build a long-lasting startup like Google.

Re:Ryan Carson responds to Paul Graham on startup hubs by danw on Thursday October 11, 2007 @06:45PM (#66572)
My bad, I must have missunderstood what you said.
Re:Ryan Carson responds to Paul Graham on startup hubs by run4yourlives on Thursday October 11, 2007 @03:15PM (#66419)
I think you nailed it.

PG doesn't view something like dropsend as a startup per se. To him that's just a small business with a chance at being successful. Ryan sees Dropsend from a founders point of view: a significant success, but not something that's going to be acquired by Google for $xxM.

They're arguing from two different positions about two different things.

Re:Ryan Carson responds to Paul Graham on startup hubs by jey on Thursday October 11, 2007 @03:01PM (#66410)
"bootstrapping and building to last, which doesn't depend on the benefits of SV as much"

Why's that? Funding, connections, deals, etc are still very important. If you want to grow your business at all, whether it's to an acquisition, IPO, or whatever... those things are still important.