Why? You get what you optimize for. Sometimes it doesn't work, but usually it does. Also in the olden days a landlord might have gotten away with bait and switch, but it seems unlikely it'll happen now.
Also given crooks, why risk more financial assets than necessary; I don't get the desire to deal with a HOA over a landlord. I don't trust that homeless person with $5, so I'll hand my wallet to that panhandler instead; what could possibly go wrong?
However, none of the above discussion about local real estate variations and trends conflicts with or relates to the observation that those who complain the most about landlords statistically seem to live as a subject of a HOA or in a condo.
Also some zoning and CCR regs are almost as bad as a HOA. And some HOA are not too bad. Most of them, on the other hand...
Funny you say that. I have had many landlords in the past when I was renting and at least 2 of them were shady and tried to take a portion out of my deposit with false claims that I did something wrong. One specific case, the landlord claimed that renters are supposed to pay for carpet cleaning when leaving. We had nothing of that in the contract. I pointed it out and her response "thats the state law" and she forwarded me a PDF of the state law for landlord/tenants. Guess what, I actually found a section in that same PDF that clearly said that tenants are not responsible for usual wear and tear cleaning unless agreed in the contract.
Overall, I think you are missing the point of why to own vs rent. I would rather deal with an HOA than a scheming landlord.