News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Motorola's Project Ara by martythemaniak on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @10:20AM (#6634259)
The way in which you shoot down something matters greatly.

When I saw phoneblocks, I was instantly reminded of designers who work without regard for their medium - a great concept with zero thought given on how to make it a reality, or even awareness of the compromises the medium will inevitably impose. If you're a front-end developer, at some point you were probably given an awesome-looking PDF, then expected to make a website/app that is a 1:1 representation of it. Of course, that never ends up happening and you have explain why it could never be a reality.

I'm really excited to see where this goes, but whatever it ends up being, I can guarantee you it won't look much like that phoneblocks video.

Re:Motorola's Project Ara by kyro on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @10:28AM (#6634320)
> "whatever it ends up being, I can guarantee you it won't look much like that phoneblocks video."

Yes, because concepts evolve. Your guarantee isn't some bold bet you're making, and I assume it's supposed to show how impractical the initial design was. But this is standard across all creative industries, from tech, to fashion, to auto: You start with what many times seems like a farfetched idea and you evolve it into a consumer product that retains your initial vision as much as possible.

Re:Motorola's Project Ara by pwhython on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @10:50AM (#6634504)
> "If you're a front-end developer, at some point you were probably given an awesome-looking PDF, then expected to make a website/app that is a 1:1 representation of it. Of course, that never ends up happening and you have explain why it could never be a reality."

I'm going off topic, but as a designer and a front-end developer, I get frustrated when the developed product isn't a 1:1 representation (when sending out the work to get coded). The end result should be a pixel perfect match of the artwork. Nothing is impossible translating an image to a website/app.

Re:Motorola's Project Ara by lewispollard on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:49AM (#6635009)
> a designer and a front-end developer

Could that be because you subconsciously make your designs using knowledge of the technical limitations of the web?