Re:Fury at Facebook as login requests “Government ID”
by DominikR on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:16AM
(#6633010)
I agree with you, in some cases the account would be absolutely unrecoverable and I am sure this happened to some users.
Still, in some cases it could be a quick solution to unlock an account. (account name matches id, no telephone number available, email validation unsafe for some reason)
You never had a government id to begin with. Maybe my government id doesn't match my account name (I know.. I violated the rules in that case.. Oh I am sooo bad). Maybe there are people with similar/the same name.
How would you make sure that 'government id' presenting person A is really the person that created any specific account?
If you cannot recover the account with the means you were provided during registration/normal usage, bad luck. Government ids won't help here. Ignoring the problems of 'faking' those (how can you judge that these documents are valid if you just get a crappy picture/a xerox or whatever, in lots of languages?) to do more harm than good.