News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @03:56AM (#6632545)
Why do people always assume that aliens would be smarter than us?
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by NhanH on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:04AM (#6632558)
Not all aliens, but generally we're only concerned with aliens that could potentially affect us. Since we can't travel that far away from our planet right now (and we know that there seems to be no life capable planet nearby - with a loose definition of "nearby"), any alien that we can meet right now would have to be quite a bit more advanced to us.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:23AM (#6634767)
The aliens haven't found us. I think the best hope of contact is if we develop interstellar travel first and go looking for them. I think the premise of the paper depends on mankind possessing this technology.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by jswhitten on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @02:17PM (#6636296)
Because the timescale of the universe is much longer than the timescale of human civilization or intelligence. The odds of any aliens we meet being at the exact same level of development as humans (to within ten thousand years or so) despite having evolved independently on a planet billions of years old, are extremely small. In the vast majority of cases they will be millions of years more advanced or millions of years less. As chimps don't build starships, it follows that almost every interstellar civilization we find will be godlike compared to us.

In other words, we are a newborn intelligent species, and newborns generally find that everyone around them is older.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @02:30PM (#6636384)
You're assuming that being older implies having more capabilities. Civilizations like ours almost certainly reach limits, either in terms of resource limits, or in terms of fundamental limits on the kinds of things that can be engineered (or both). The fact we've never run into any alien tourists or explorers, despite thousands of years of record keeping and being able to search the earth for alien artifacts, and our own research into star travel support the idea that it's impossible.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by Houshalter on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:37AM (#6632664)
They would likely be millions of years ahead of us. It's very unlikely two intelligent species would happen to evolve within a few thousand years of each other. So either natural evolution, or more likely self-modification, would have had tons of time to improve. Not to mention artificial intelligence.

They could be millions or billions of times more intelligent than us. And imagine a mind the size of the Earth, or the size of Jupiter, with the energy of their entire star.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @11:13AM (#6634698)
There's reason to think that we're maxed out on intelligence. Our heads are about as big as could fit through the birth canal. A brain as big as a planet couldn't possibly work, and if it had the energy of a star, it would be made of plasma at millions of degrees Kelvin.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by Houshalter on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @12:11PM (#6635230)
We are actually only on the cusp of intelligence. The very first things to emerge from evolution capable of building a technological civilization. If it were possible for chimpanzee brains to build a technological civilization, we would be having this conversation at an even lower level of intelligence. The brain was designed by evolution, a very stupid and slow process. We are the result of iteratively improving what worked good at controlling locomotion in fish. Certainly we can make improvements, certainly we can do better.

The fact that the human brain is limited to fitting through the birth canal is a great example. With c-sections that isn't particularly relevant, and computers/AI aren't limited in size or energy requirements at all (or at least not anywhere near the same constraints that humans have.) So imagine if brains that constraint was removed and you made brains dozens, hundreds, or even millions of times larger.

You could build a computer the size of a planet, though it would require a ridiculous amount of technological ability. The energy of a star doesn't mean literally as hot as a star, but something like thousands of solar panels to efficiently collect as much of the energy as possible for powering the enormous computer. It was just an example of what the limits of technology might be.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @02:39PM (#6636465)
> The fact that the human brain is limited to fitting through the birth canal is a great example. With c-sections that isn't particularly relevant

A bright future for mankind, but less great for womankind. We may need to figure out how to use elephants as surrogate mothers.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by Houshalter on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @03:11PM (#6636693)
Or test tube babies, or completely artificial brains.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:07AM (#6640118)
Or, if we get really good at bioengineering, we could figure out how to fit more brainpower into less space, and thus allow the skull to shrink a little bit.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @12:25PM (#6635365)
I don't think you could have as much energy as a star in an amount of mass no more than a star without being as hot as one.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by Houshalter on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @01:17PM (#6635816)
Probably not but that's not what I'm suggesting at all. Think of something like surrounding the star with giant solar panels.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @01:34PM (#6635974)
Maybe I misread you. Did you mean a mind that has the energy of a star at its command? Still, that's more energy than you could possibly use. Consider that the sun has far more mass than the rest of the solar system put together, and all of it is extremely hot.
Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by eli_gottlieb on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @02:39PM (#6636467)
A) Our cognitive structure is not actually that stupid. Note that many-layered neural networks are at the forefront of modern Machine Learning, a discipline carried out by educated, technology-using sapients who will immediately switch to some better technique the instant they find one. Indeed, there is active research into better learning techniques. Neural networks may not be the peak, but they're Pretty Good enough that they didn't evolve "by mistake" in nature.

B) We are still evolving. The big overwhelming FACT of civilization didn't halt our evolution, it just changed the nature of the selection pressures. Whereas raw, physical survivability was once the prime selection factor, civilization has made reproductive desirability, social cooperation, and parenting ability (all inter-related but nonidentical) the larger selection pressures on human genomes.

C) The big new adaptation that made us humans what we are was only maybe intelligence. It was probably extelligence: the ability to store knowledge in the social group rather than the individual. That way, you can build your collective knowledge over time.

D) You would have to be a stupidly, suicidally cancerous civilization to go around converting whole planets into tools.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by Houshalter on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @04:07PM (#6637099)
Artificial neural networks are only one method among many, and they are only vaguely similar to biological ones. Neural nets are only good at exactly what biological ones are good at; pattern recognition. They can't do any optimization at all. They aren't going to be rewriting their own code any time soon.

Modern computers are millions of times faster than the human brain, and can in theory be made much more energy efficient and compact and probably cheaper.

Yes we are still evolving, though at a ridiculously slow pace. And the traits that are currently spreading aren't exactly good. The genes responsible for sociopathy are becoming more frequent since we don't live in small communities anymore. Intelligence is being strongly selected against at the moment as counter-intuitive as that seems. Less intelligent individuals tend to reproduce far more frequently for whatever reason.

"Extelligence" doesn't really explain much. Sure a mind on it's own might not accomplish much, but we still have to explain what it is about human minds that allow them to think and learn in the first place. Can apes be taught language? If they were would they gain higher level intelligence or does it take more than that? I bet it isn't that simple.

>You would have to be a stupidly, suicidally cancerous civilization to go around converting whole planets into tools.

I don't know where your preference comes from but I would love to see the planets get converted into giant computers and minds. We should optimize the universe for our values, rather than preserving the random state it was put in by nature.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:00AM (#6640101)
>I don't know where your preference comes from but I would love to see the planets get converted into giant computers and minds. We should optimize the universe for our values, rather than preserving the random state it was put in by nature.

Congratulations! You're the first person outside /r/hpmor to make my Chemical Shed List for Irresponsibly-Applied Phlebotinum! When shit gets real, I will take you out behind the chemical sheds and shoot you.

People like the so-called random state things were put in by nature. Saturn, for instance, is pretty the way it is. Hell, think about it this way: what if I suggested that your house you actually live in is simply suboptimal as a house, and should instead be converted into a huge brain I can use for thinking? After all, it's just another step in my optimizing the universe for my values, which apparently include adolescent dick-waving and solving lots of math problems rather than a human civilization with people to talk to.

Well, you shouldn't want to do that, because after all, you need a place to live. More broadly, even if you've "gone virtual" (as you indicate some desire to do in occasional hard-SF threads), you're still a human being, and you're supposed to have sentimental attachments. Sentimental attachments are, after all, what make us human in the first place.

This whole "planet-sized X" thing, for all X other than planets, is basically just another adolescent power fantasy. Consider that if Ultimate Power, or some semblance thereof, seems to be your goal in life, there may in fact be something wrong with you. I can't actually think of anything a human being wants other than raw power that is served by wrecking entire planets.

Real life is not a scifi novel, not even the finer grade of scifi novel.

>"Extelligence" doesn't really explain much. Sure a mind on it's own might not accomplish much, but we still have to explain what it is about human minds that allow them to think and learn in the first place. Can apes be taught language? If they were would they gain higher level intelligence or does it take more than that? I bet it isn't that simple.

Actually, gorillas have been taught simple sign-language before and can form coherent sentences. Chimpanzees have been observed learning and passing down more advanced tool-using skills than we thought they were capable of. Human children, raised without exposure to language and culture, don't naturally turn out as civilized "human beings" of the kind we expect to meet.

The Big Secret is culture.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by Houshalter on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @08:55AM (#6640382)
There are trillions of planets in the universe. Maybe even in our own galaxy. Converting a few of them to computers is pretty minor. Your preference is about as arbitrary as not wanting to destroy any trees in the entire world, or even not wanting to kill a single bacteria or move a single pebble.

I have no idea what kind of goals and desires a futuristic civilization will have. I can imagine a lot of possible goals that could be possibly benefit from giant computers and other mega-projects. But even short of that, you could still just say why not?

The universe is our sandbox. The sand isn't intelligent, it doesn't care what shape it's in. And it wasn't put in it's current shape for any particular reason. But we can build beautiful castles in it that we appreciate. We can play and have fun in it, and it won't matter to the sand one way or the other, but it will matter to us. And at the end of the day the tide will probably wipe it all away anyways.

Apes still have massively reduced brain sizes and are missing many of the adaptions humans had. As far as I am aware teaching them language was only partially successful and they still are nowhere near human level. And it still tells us absolutely nothing about how the brain actually works.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:24PM (#6637937)
Trying to reproduce human-style decision making in a piece of software is only done as a last resort. It's a small miracle whenever it works. Interestingly, genetic algorithms seem to do more interesting things than neural networks. What does that say about brains vs evolution?

> civilization has made reproductive desirability, social cooperation, and parenting ability (all inter-related but nonidentical) the larger selection pressures on human genomes

Looking at the people that have the biggest families, it's hard to say what, exactly, is being selected for. They seem to like children.

> You would have to be a stupidly, suicidally cancerous civilization to go around converting whole planets into tools.

We've been converting the earth into a tool.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by eli_gottlieb on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @03:40AM (#6640045)
>We've been converting the earth into a tool.

And, look at that, it's killing us.

Admittedly, since we've known that overexploiting the Earth's resources would do that for something like 50 years now, I don't so much blame humanity in general as the narrow but powerful subset who decided it was better to overexploit and destroy civilization than to make a bit less money.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by mtdewcmu on Wednesday October 30, 2013 @04:24AM (#6640174)
It's been pretty much essential. Earth's entire land area used to be wilderness. Now a substantial proportion of it is farmland, without which we wouldn't eat. It's a tool for enabling civilization.

It hasn't really started killing us yet -- the population is expanding. This civilization may and probably will collapse, like the Romans, but I'm not sure exactly how a civilization could grow exponentially forever, so it's kind of inevitable.

Re:Krugman’s Theory of Interstellar Trade by alan_cx on Tuesday October 29, 2013 @06:52AM (#6633132)
Because we are.