I've considered using a simple stickies app, but there's something about pencil and paper that I find beneficial — or at the least, comforting — and I haven't quite put my finger on it. Not sure if it's the ability to do free-form sketching, or that I can quickly physically shuffle/order/arrange the cards, or that I can jot things down without needing to be at my computer/on a mobile device — or just being able to step/look away from a screen for a bit.
I'm thinking most likely it's that whatever added functionality or benefits I would get from using an app to manage this stuff would be offset by me fiddling around with features, settings, tweaks, etc., and screwing around "evaluating" different tools.
I discussed it with a another friend of mine (a business guy) who similarly prefers notes/notebooks and we seemed to hone in on the fact that its superiority over non-physical mediums comes from its freeform nature. The freeform nature allows you to record things in a format that more accurately models the way your mind works. This makes it easier to come back to and have your brain go "Aha yes I have a memory stored for this data because I created this note". With a physical medium, you're never (or at least, much less so) forced into any format that was created by another person (to-do apps, etc.).
I think meta-productivity is just too much damn fun to leave alone.
It also provides a visual level of how deep you are into "shaving the yak" - once you're 10 levels into a problem, it becomes easy to forget what the original problem was.
http://projects.csail.mit.edu/gsb/old-archive/gsb-archive/gs...